The Eight Families: An Audit for the Non-Quantum Limit and the Non-Quantum Approximation
Introduction
The scope. Fifty-six articles, in eight families of seven. The families are the four sectors — Schrödinger, Klein–Gordon, Dirac, Proca — each taken free and taken coupled to an electromagnetic connection. The seven slots of a family are the element form, the polar form, the two variational articles, the two Fourier articles, and the Fourier-plus-variational element article.
The question. Which of the seven carry something a non-quantum limit or a non-quantum approximation can use. The answer is a ranking, and the ranking differs from family to family.
The verdict in one paragraph. In the Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon families the polar article carries the whole limit and the Fourier article carries its symbol. In the Dirac family the polar article carries the four fluid brackets, which are the exact form of the limit's equations, and the limit itself is worked out outside these articles. In the Proca family the free field cannot host the limit at all, because it has no phase: its polar article is the obstruction and says why, while its Fourier element article and its variational polar article still carry the ray content a vector limit needs, three polarizations and a rank-three constraint. The coupled articles are the ones that can host the limit, and there the Fourier element article and the triple are the strongest. The five tables after the definitions grade all fifty-six.
What is not here. No new equation, no new quantity, no re-derivation. The audit reads what the corpus already states and says what each statement is worth for the limit. Where a claim is quoted with a number, the number was recomputed.
The Two Definitions
The Non-Quantum Limit
A regime, not an operation on the algebra. Take a solution and write it as an amplitude and a phase,
$$ \tilde\Xi=A\,e^{i\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}}\,\xi , \qquad S=\hbar\,\theta_{\mathrm{pha}} , $$
with $A>0$ real and central, $S$ the action, real and central, and $\xi$ a module element taken locally constant. The limit is the regime
$$ \epsilon=\frac{1}{k_{\Phi}L}=\frac{\hbar}{p\,L}\longrightarrow 0 , $$
where $L$ is the length over which $A$ varies and $k_{\Phi}=|\vec p|/\hbar$. The parameter is the reduced phase wavelength over the amplitude's length. The limit is $L\gg\lambda_{\Phi}$.
What survives. The phase obeys the eikonal equation and the amplitude obeys a transport equation. The momentum is the phase gradient, $\vec p=\nabla S$, the velocity is a function of the momentum, and the ray is a characteristic of the eikonal.
What fails, and the refusals are part of the definition. The limit does not commute with superposition: the sum of two rays is not a ray. It does not select a subalgebra of $\mathbb{B}$, so it is not a contraction to the centre. It does not produce a state: a ray and a density are not elements of the module. At a caustic the amplitude diverges, $\epsilon$ is not small, and the ray picture ends.
Three things the limit is not. It is not $\hbar\to0$ at fixed mass, which deepens the mass term, $k_m=mc/\hbar\to\infty$, while it softens the bracket. It is not $\hbar\to0$ at fixed wave number, which drives $\beta=|v|/c\to0$ and returns a member of the non-relativistic family. It is not the statement that the equation is classical, because a classical field equation is still a wave equation and still has rays to be found.
The Non-Quantum Approximation
A truncation with a stated order and a stated remainder. The approximation is the series in $\epsilon$ cut at a definite power. Three orders are named.
| order | what it adds | name |
|---|---|---|
| $\epsilon^{0}$ | the eikonal alone: a mass shell or a Hamilton–Jacobi equation, and a polarization condition | geometric optics |
| $\epsilon^{1}$ | the transport equation for the amplitude, and the sub-leading phase | semiclassical, or WKB |
| $\epsilon^{2}$ | the quantum potential as a source for the phase's second correction | the first quantum correction |
The distinction is practical. The limit says what survives and what breaks. The approximation says how large the discarded piece is. The quantum potential makes the point sharp: for a Gaussian waist the ratio $|Q|/(E-V)$ is $\epsilon^{2}|x^{2}/4\sigma^{2}-1/2|$, which vanishes at $x=\sqrt2\sigma$ and reaches one at $|x|\simeq2\sigma/\epsilon$. No value of $\epsilon$ makes the expansion uniform, and that is a fact about the approximation and not about the limit.
One rule follows, and it governs every formula below. Only derivatives carry a power of $\epsilon$. Coefficients do not. The mass enters as the number $\mu=k_m/k_{\Phi}=1/(\gamma\beta)$, and $\mu$ is not expanded: at $\beta=0.01$ it is $99.995$, and sending it to infinity is the other limit.
Why the Limit Needs a Phase
A limit on an amplitude and a phase needs both. The step that orders the equation is the comparison of $\nabla S$ with $\hbar\nabla\ln A$. Where there is no phase there is nothing to compare.
Three of the four free sectors have a phase. The Schrödinger field is central on its central branch, with the angle $\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}$. The Klein–Gordon field is central, with the same angle. The Dirac field has the angle inside its four-factor word.
The free Proca field has none. Its values are anti-Hermitian, its polar word is a scale times a boost, and the phase factor $e^{i\vartheta}$ maps the material sector off itself. The free chart's norm is $\mp \varrho^{2}$, whose argument is a sign. There is no continuous angle, and the free Proca field cannot host the limit of this article.
The coupling repairs it. On the complex carrier the word carries $e^{i\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}}$, the norm is $\varrho^{2}e^{2i\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}}$, and the argument is twice a continuous angle. The charge and the phase slot are one object. This is why the Proca family inverts the pattern of the other three: for Proca the coupled articles are the ones that can be limited, and the free ones cannot.
How the Formulas Are Written
Six steps, and every family uses the same six. What changes is the word in step one, and the symbol rule in step five.
Step one: write the word, and check that a phase exists. For a scalar or a first-order field,
$$ \tilde\Xi=A\,e^{i\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}}\,\varepsilon e_t , \qquad \varepsilon=\pm1 . $$
For the Dirac field the word keeps all four factors, $\varrho\,e^{i\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}}\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}\tilde u_{\mathrm r}$. For the Proca field the free word is $\varrho\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}$ on the spacelike branch and $\varepsilon ir\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}$ on the timelike one, with no phase; the coupled word is $\varrho\,e^{i\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}}\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}\tilde u_{\mathrm r}$, with one.
Step two: name the three wave numbers and the two lengths. $k_m=mc/\hbar$, $k_t'=E/(\hbar c)$, $\vec k_{\Phi}=\vec p/\hbar$, then $\lambda_{\Phi}=1/k_{\Phi}$ and $L$. Introduce no wave number that absorbs none of the mass, the momentum or the energy.
Step three: rescale, and rescale nothing else. Write
$$ y_\eta=\frac{r_\eta}{L} , \qquad \tau=\frac{r'_t}{L}=\frac{c\,t}{L} , \qquad \Theta=\epsilon\,\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}=\frac{\epsilon\,S}{\hbar} , \qquad \chi=A , $$
so that $\Theta$ is of order one and varies on the scale $y\sim1$, and expand $\Theta=\Theta_0+\epsilon\Theta_1+\ldots$ and $\chi=\chi_0+\epsilon\chi_1+\ldots$. Every derivative then carries one power: $\partial_\mu=\epsilon\,\lambda_{\Phi}^{-1}\partial_{y_\mu}$. The mass does not: $k_m^{2}$ stays as the coefficient $\mu^{2}=k_m^{2}/k_{\Phi}^{2}$ at every order.
Step four: collect by derivative order, and write the exact pair first. For a central field of second order the two slots rescaled are
$$ \left(\partial_\tau\Theta\right)^{2}-\left|\nabla_y\Theta\right|^{2}=\mu^{2}-\epsilon^{2}\frac{L^{2}\Box_\Phi\chi}{\chi} , \qquad \partial_\tau\left(\chi^{2}\partial_\tau\Theta\right)-\nabla_y\cdot\left(\chi^{2}\nabla_y\Theta\right)=0 . $$
Read the two displays separately, because they behave differently. The first carries the mass at order zero as the coefficient $\mu^{2}$ and the amplitude's curvature at order $\epsilon^{2}$; the second carries no $\epsilon$ at all. That asymmetry is the whole content of the phrase "the limit is a limit of the pair": the eikonal is truncated and the transport is not.
A first-order equation replaces the mass shell by a Hamilton–Jacobi equation and keeps the same structure. The mass coefficient $\mu^{2}$ is then absent, a potential takes its place, and the $\epsilon^{0}$ row below becomes $\partial_\tau\Theta_0+\lvert\nabla_y\Theta_0\rvert^{2}/2+U=0$ in the inertial frame. The transport, the order counting and the quantum potential are unchanged.
The real slot, order by order.
| order | what it says | name |
|---|---|---|
| $\epsilon^{0}$ | $\left(\partial_\tau\Theta_0\right)^{2}-\lvert\nabla_y\Theta_0\rvert^{2}=\mu^{2}$ | the eikonal |
| $\epsilon^{1}$ | $2\mathcal{V}\cdot\partial\Theta_1=0$, so the phase's first correction is frozen along the ray | the sub-leading phase |
| $\epsilon^{2}$ | the amplitude's curvature enters as a source for $\Theta_2$ | the quantum potential |
with $\mathcal{V}=\left(\partial_\tau\Theta_0,-\nabla_y\Theta_0\right)$ the ray's direction. The imaginary slot is the transport, and it is exact at every order, which is why it never appears in this table.
Step five: check the eikonal against the symbol. Replace $\partial_\mu$ by $i\pi_\mu$, with $\pi_\mu=\hbar k_\mu+ϙ A_\mu$, and write the symbol $\sigma(\pi)$. The order-$\epsilon^{0}$ equation must be $\det\sigma(\partial S)=0$.
Two rules govern this step, and both are consequences of the order of the equation.
For a second-order operator the mass sits at order zero with the two derivatives, so the eikonal is the massive dispersion. Klein–Gordon and Proca are of this kind.
For a first-order operator the mass sits one order below the derivative, so the eikonal is the massless dispersion and the mass shell appears only in the square. This was checked on the Dirac symbol: with $k_m=0.7$ and $\pi^{2}=0.5$, just off the mass shell, $\det(\gamma\cdot\pi-k_m)=(\pi^{2}-k_m^{2})^{2}=1.0\times10^{-4}$, while the principal determinant is $\det(\gamma\cdot\pi)=(\pi^{2})^{2}=0.25$, nonzero. The principal symbol of a Dirac operator knows nothing of the mass. The limit must therefore be taken on the composed or squared operator, which is exactly what the chiral pair does when it is squared.
Step six: write the output and the error. The output is the triple $p_\mu=\partial_\mu S$, the transport equation, and the quantum potential. The error is
$$ \rho=\frac{|Q|}{E-V}=\epsilon^{2}\left|\frac{1}{k_{\Phi}^{2}}\frac{\Delta_\Phi A}{A}\right| . $$
Three warnings, and each one is a way to write a wrong display.
Never expand the algebra in $\hbar$. The algebra carries no $\hbar$; it carries $k_m$, and a limit on $\hbar$ at fixed mass is a limit on $1/k_m$, which stiffens the propagator.
Never let a varying amplitude pass as a symbol. A symbol exists at a mode, and a mode has a constant amplitude. Where the amplitude curves, the discarded term is $\Box_\Phi A/A$, which no function of the wave number can hold.
Never take the zero set of the determinant as the whole eikonal for a constrained field. For Proca and for Dirac the determinant vanishes on a set larger than the physical polarizations, and the polarization condition has to be added. The mass supplies it for Proca, and the composition supplies it for Dirac.
The Ranking Tables
Four grades, and each article gets one.
| mark | meaning |
|---|---|
| U | useful: it carries the eikonal, the transport, the symbol or the error of the limit |
| O | useful as an obstruction: it explains why the limit cannot be written in its family |
| P | partial: it carries one ingredient — a bound, a constraint, a reading — and not the eikonal |
| N | not useful for the limit: a precondition, or nothing the limit can use |
A useful article need not be able to host the limit. In free Proca the symbol and the constraint are useful, and the field has no phase to order. The two questions are separate: what an article carries, and whether its family admits the limit at all.
Table 1: The Whole Corpus at a Glance
| family | element | polar | variational, element | variational, polar | Fourier, element | Fourier, polar | Fourier + variational |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Schrödinger, free | N | U | N | U | P | P | P |
| Schrödinger, coupled | N | U | N | U | U | P | P |
| Klein–Gordon, free | N | U | N | U | P | U | P |
| Klein–Gordon, coupled | N | U | N | U | U | P | P |
| Dirac, free | N | U | N | U | P | P | P |
| Dirac, coupled | N | U | N | U | P | P | U |
| Proca, free | P | O | N | U | U | O | P |
| Proca, coupled | P | U | N | P | U | P | U |
Counts. Twenty-one useful, two useful as obstructions, nineteen partial, fourteen not useful, out of fifty-six.
Five patterns, and they are the audit's result.
The polar article is useful in seven families and an obstruction in the eighth. It is the column to read first, in every family but free Proca.
The variational polar article is useful in seven families and partial in the eighth. In seven families the two polar articles carry the limit; in free Proca one carries it and the other is the obstruction.
The element form and the variational element article are useful in no family. They give the equation and the action, and the limit needs the equation separated into two real parts.
The Fourier element article is useful in three of the four coupled families and in free Proca, and partial in the three free families and in coupled Dirac. A free second-order symbol is a scalar and says little; a coupled symbol is a translation, and a Proca symbol is a projector.
The Fourier-plus-variational triple is useful only for coupled Dirac and coupled Proca. Elsewhere it is the action at one mode and nothing more.
Table 2: The Useful Articles
| family | article | what it gives |
|---|---|---|
| Schrödinger, free | The Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the exact Madelung pair, and $Q$ named |
| Schrödinger, free | The Lagrangian and the Schrödinger Equation in Polar Variables | the same pair from the action; the rotor–boost cross term is not optional |
| Schrödinger, coupled | The Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the covariant pair, $Q$ unchanged, the kinetic momentum |
| Schrödinger, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Polar Variables | the covariant Lagrangian and the shifted canonical pair |
| Schrödinger, coupled | The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol is the free symbol at $\pi=\hbar k+ϙ A$, residual zero |
| Klein–Gordon, free | The Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the exact pair, mass shell plus $2mQ$ |
| Klein–Gordon, free | The Lagrangian and the Klein–Gordon Equation in Polar Variables | the chart action with $g_{ab}$ and the $\cosh$/$\sinh$ structure |
| Klein–Gordon, free | The Fourier Transform and the Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | $Q$ priced on four shapes, $0.000$ to $1155.53$ |
| Klein–Gordon, coupled | The Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the covariant pair and the circulation $2\pi\hbar n+ϙ\Phi_B$ |
| Klein–Gordon, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Polar Variables | the covariant chart action |
| Klein–Gordon, coupled | The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol at $\pi$ |
| Dirac, free | The Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the four brackets, and the mass shell as frame unitarity |
| Dirac, free | The Lagrangian and the Dirac Equation in Polar Variables | the kinetic term, four vanishing momenta, one second-class bracket |
| Dirac, coupled | The Coupled Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | $\tilde K_{\Phi,\mathrm{gco}}$, the translated hyperboloid, the gauge moving only the angle |
| Dirac, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Dirac Equation in Polar Variables | seven momenta fixed or vanishing, six constraints |
| Dirac, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Dirac Equation in Momentum Space | the coupling is a translation of the argument; centrality only at zero field strength |
| Proca, free | The Lagrangian and the Proca Equation in Polar Variables | Hessian rank three, the Lorenz condition as the secondary constraint |
| Proca, free | The Fourier Transform and the Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the eigenvalues, the determinant, rank one on shell, $3-0=3$ |
| Proca, coupled | The Coupled Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the four-factor word with a phase; the momentum shift |
| Proca, coupled | The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the curvature is multiplication and cannot enter the principal symbol |
| Proca, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Proca Equation in Momentum Space | two reflected roots, the constraint $a'_t=\vec k_{\Phi}\cdot\vec a/k'_t$, the absent $\pi_t^{2}$ |
Table 3: Useful as an Obstruction
| family | article | what it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Proca, free | The Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the two-branch word is a scale and a boost, with no phase, so the limit cannot be written |
| Proca, free | The Fourier Transform and the Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the symbol is even in the wave number, so there is no odd slot and no guidance equation |
Table 4: The Partial Articles
| family | article | what it gives, and what it lacks |
|---|---|---|
| Schrödinger, free | The Fourier Transform and the Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the zero set is two points, so no mass shell and no dispersion to eikonalise |
| Schrödinger, free | The Fourier Transform and the Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the word fails exactly on the spectrum; a bound, not a limit |
| Schrödinger, free | The Lagrangian and the Schrödinger Equation in Momentum Space | the fixed-frequency action is the symbol; the inversion is single-valued |
| Schrödinger, coupled | The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the symbol needs a constant bracket: one mode to twenty-seven as the chirp rises |
| Schrödinger, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Momentum Space | reality term by term, no cancellation |
| Klein–Gordon, free | The Fourier Transform and the Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol is the scalar $k^{2}-k_m^{2}$; usable only at a constant amplitude |
| Klein–Gordon, free | The Lagrangian and the Klein–Gordon Equation in Momentum Space | the form at a mode and its two roots |
| Klein–Gordon, coupled | The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the symbol's chart reading |
| Klein–Gordon, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Momentum Space | the form at a mode |
| Dirac, free | The Fourier Transform and the Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol is odd, $\lvert\sigma(-K)+\sigma(K)\rvert=2k_m$ |
| Dirac, free | The Fourier Transform and the Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the transform of a phase is a place; no momentum-space word |
| Dirac, free | The Lagrangian and the Dirac Equation in Momentum Space | one number, $N=\pi^{2}-k_m^{2}$, central |
| Dirac, coupled | The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol at $\pi$ |
| Dirac, coupled | The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the chart reading of the symbol |
| Proca, free | The Proca Equation: Massive Spin One in Biquaternionic Form | the dispersion and three polarizations; no ordering |
| Proca, free | The Lagrangian and the Proca Equation in Momentum Space | the longitudinal coefficient $\tfrac12k_m^{2}$, the absent $\omega^{2}$ in $A_0^{2}$ |
| Proca, coupled | The Coupled Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the complex carrier and the covariant Lorenz condition |
| Proca, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Proca Equation in Polar Variables | the action as a quadratic form; the Hessian's regularity is open |
| Proca, coupled | The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the gauge-invariant content is the obstruction; no preferred sign |
Table 5: The Articles That Carry Nothing for the Limit
| family | article | why not |
|---|---|---|
| Schrödinger, free | The Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the equation and its flow, nothing separated or ordered |
| Schrödinger, free | The Lagrangian and the Schrödinger Equation | the action and its Noether charge |
| Schrödinger, coupled | The Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the equation and covariance |
| Schrödinger, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation | the action and its two currents |
| Klein–Gordon, free | The Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the equation, the dispersion, the current |
| Klein–Gordon, free | The Lagrangian and the Klein–Gordon Equation | the action and its currents |
| Klein–Gordon, coupled | The Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the equation and covariance |
| Klein–Gordon, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation | the action and its currents |
| Dirac, free | The Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the chiral pair and its solutions |
| Dirac, free | The Lagrangian and the Dirac Equation | the action and its currents |
| Dirac, coupled | The Coupled Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the pair with a connection, covariance |
| Dirac, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Dirac Equation | the action and its currents |
| Proca, free | The Lagrangian and the Proca Equation | the action, the Lorenz condition from the variation |
| Proca, coupled | The Lagrangian and the Coupled Proca Equation | the mass term's invariance, the current, an open normalization |
Read the five tables together and the rule is one sentence. The limit lives in the polar articles and their variational companions, the dispersion lives in the coupled Fourier articles, and the element form and the variational element article never carry it.
The Twelve Articles to Write
Six families outside Proca, two routes each. The polar article gives the limit by substitution into the equation; the variational polar article gives the same limit from the action. The new articles carry steps three to six of How the Formulas Are Written: rescaling, collection by derivative order, the symbol check, the output and the error. Steps one and two stay in the parents.
Route One: Substitution into the Equation
| title | family | status |
|---|---|---|
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Free Schrödinger Equation | Schrödinger, free | written; replaces The WKB Approximation and the Hamilton–Jacobi Equation in Biquaternionic Form, whose phase-integral content moved to The Semiclassical Expansion and the Instanton Gas |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Coupled Schrödinger Equation | Schrödinger, coupled | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Free Klein–Gordon Equation | Klein–Gordon, free | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation | Klein–Gordon, coupled | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Free Dirac Equation | Dirac, free | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Coupled Dirac Equation | Dirac, coupled | written |
Route Two: The Variational Principle
| title | family | status |
|---|---|---|
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Free Schrödinger Equation using the Variational Principle | Schrödinger, free | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Coupled Schrödinger Equation using the Variational Principle | Schrödinger, coupled | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Free Klein–Gordon Equation using the Variational Principle | Klein–Gordon, free | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation using the Variational Principle | Klein–Gordon, coupled | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Free Dirac Equation using the Variational Principle | Dirac, free | written |
| The Non-Quantum Limit of the Coupled Dirac Equation using the Variational Principle | Dirac, coupled | written |
Nine were new when this audit was written. Three of route one existed as other articles; the first two are now rewritten under their own titles, and the third pair is now rewritten under theirs — the source article keeps the material and does not carry the title. Twelve titles, twenty-four rows of status across the two tables, no row standing for another row. All twelve are written. Both routes are complete, each article under its own title. Relativistic Mechanics from the Dirac Wave stands as the Dirac pair's source for the flow, the force and the checks; the two Dirac variational articles report what their parent's first-order action does and does not allow — no group to delete on the free side, and the connection entering the potential, hence no cost in accuracy unless the field has a curl. Relativistic Mechanics from the Dirac Wave is a source for the Dirac pair and not one of the twelve.
The two routes are equivalent on solutions and not as derivations. They yield the same pair — continuity for $\varrho^{2}$ and the eikonal with $Q$ — and the variational route adds the constraints, the frame metric and the cross-term warning that the substitution route cannot state. The pairing is therefore worth writing twice: once as an equation, once as an action.
Family 1: The Schrödinger Equation, Free
The family. The element form, the polar form, the two variational articles, the two Fourier articles, and the triple.
What the Seven Carry
| article | what it carries for the limit | worth |
|---|---|---|
| The Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the exact pair: continuity for $\varrho^{2}$ and Hamilton–Jacobi with $Q=-\hbar^{2}(\Delta_\Phi \varrho/\varrho)/(2m)$, the central collapse being Madelung's | the limit's whole content |
| The Lagrangian and the Schrödinger Equation in Polar Variables | the same pair from the action, with the rotor–boost cross term, and the finding that dropping the cross term leaves no general solution | the limit's content, with a warning |
| The Fourier Transform and the Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol is one element, its zero set two real points, even about $h_t$ and not about zero: no second time derivative, hence no mass shell | the approximation's structure |
| The Fourier Transform and the Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the symbol's word fails exactly on the spectrum; the phase is a character and the rotor is not | the approximation's reading |
| The Lagrangian and the Schrödinger Equation in Momentum Space | the fixed-frequency action is the symbol; the Legendre slope is $\hbar$, so the inversion is single-valued | the action at a mode |
| The Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the equation and its flow | precondition |
| The Lagrangian and the Schrödinger Equation | the action and its Noether charge | precondition |
The Verdict
The polar article is the family's limit article. It prints the two exact equations and names $Q$. Nothing in the family adds to them.
The variational polar article adds one thing the limit needs. The cross term between the phase rate and the rotor's angular rate is not optional: dropping it leaves a system with no general solution. A limit written from a Lagrangian that omits it is not a limit of the equation.
The Fourier element article carries the structural fact. The symbol's zero set is two points and not a surface. That is the arithmetic of a first-order equation, and it is why this sector has no mass shell and no antiparticle.
The gap is closed. The Non-Quantum Limit of the Free Schrödinger Equation now carries this family's limit in full: the ansatz, the pair, the norm reading $\langle\nabla S\rangle_\natural/2m=E-V$, the transport amplitude, the van Vleck determinant and the size of the error. The phase-integral content — the Maslov phases, the Bohr–Sommerfeld condition and the tunnelling exponent — sits in The Semiclassical Expansion and the Instanton Gas, because it is a consequence of the approximation and not of the limit.
How the Formulas Go
Write the central word and substitute. With $h_t e_t+i\vec h_\Psi$ the Hamiltonian and $H=\vec p^{2}/2m+V$,
$$ i\hbar\,\partial_t\psi=-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}\Delta_\Phi\psi+V\psi , \qquad \psi=A\,e^{iS/\hbar} . $$
The two real equations are exact, and neither is approximate.
$$ \partial_t S+\frac{|\nabla S|^{2}}{2m}+V-\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}\frac{\Delta_\Phi A}{A}=0 , \qquad \partial_t A^{2}+\nabla\cdot\left(\frac{A^{2}\nabla S}{m}\right)=0 . $$
The truncation is one term. Drop the third term of the first equation; its ratio to the kinetic term is $\epsilon^{2}$. The eikonal is
$$ \partial_t S+\frac{|\nabla S|^{2}}{2m}+V=0 , $$
and the transport is untouched, because it never contained $Q$. The gradient of the eikonal gives $\partial_t\vec p+(\vec v\cdot\nabla)\vec p=-\nabla V$, hence $m\ddot{\vec r}=-\nabla V$ with $\vec v=\nabla S/m$ and $E=-\partial_t S$.
One sentence to write and not to forget. The continuity equation is not approximated, so the limit delivers a flow and its density and not a single trajectory.
Family 2: The Schrödinger Equation, Coupled
What the Seven Carry
| article | what it carries for the limit | worth |
|---|---|---|
| The Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the covariant pair with $Q$ unchanged, the kinetic momentum $\nabla S+ϙ\vec A$, the potential energy $-ϙ\varphi$ | the limit's whole content |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Polar Variables | the covariant Lagrangian, the momenta, the same flow with the canonical pair shifted to the kinetic pair | the limit's content from the action |
| The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the coupled symbol is the free symbol at the shifted argument, verified over one hundred draws with zero residual; the scalar potential translates the pair, the vector potential separates it; the effective mass is the bare mass | the limit's symbol |
| The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the transform commutes with the gauge transformation; the symbol is faithful only where the bracket is constant, measured at $1.00$, $5.80$ and $26.53$ modes for chirp rates $0$, $1$ and $4$ | the approximation's validity |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Momentum Space | the reality is term by term, no cancellation; $\sigma_{\mathrm{gco}}$ is a function of $\mathcal E$ and $\vec\pi$ alone | the action at a mode |
| The Coupled Schrödinger Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the equation and covariance | precondition |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Schrödinger Equation | the action and its two currents | precondition |
The Verdict
This is the cleanest family in the corpus for the limit. The coupling enters only the phase bracket, because a central scalar cannot reach the scale, the boost axis or the rotor axis. So the covariant pair is the free pair with two substitutions and no third change.
The Fourier element article carries the sharpest single statement of the family. The coupled symbol is exactly the free symbol at $\pi=\hbar k+ϙ A$. Translation and nothing else. The consequence for the limit is immediate: the eikonal is the free eikonal with the kinetic momentum, and the curvature enters one order later.
The Fourier polar article carries the warning. A symbol is a model of a constant bracket. Where the connection is chirped, the mode count rises from one to twenty-seven, so the symbol is no longer a description of the field. A limit that needs a symbol needs a connection that is slowly varying on the scale $L$, and no article states that condition.
How the Formulas Go
Substitute the covariant derivative into the word, not into the answer.
$$ \mathcal A^{\mathrm{gco}}_t=\mathcal A_t-\frac{iϙ}{\hbar}\varphi , \qquad \mathcal A^{\mathrm{gco}}_\eta=\mathcal A_\eta+\frac{iϙ}{\hbar}A_\eta , $$
each addition a central imaginary number, so only the phase bracket moves.
The pair is the free pair with the kinetic momentum.
$$ \partial_t S+\frac{|\nabla S+ϙ\vec A|^{2}}{2m}-ϙ\varphi+Q=0 , \qquad \partial_t \varrho^{2}+\nabla\cdot\left(\varrho^{2}\frac{\nabla S+ϙ\vec A}{m}\right)=0 . $$
The eikonal is the dispersion at the shifted momentum, and the force is its gradient. Put $\vec\pi=\nabla S+ϙ\vec A$ and $\mathcal E=\partial_t S+ϙ\varphi$. Then
$$ \frac{d\vec\pi}{dt}=ϙ\left(\vec E+\vec v\times\vec B\right) , \qquad \vec v=\frac{\vec\pi}{m} , $$
which is the Lorentz force: the two terms that do not fit its pattern cancel because $\vec v$ is parallel to $\vec\pi$.
Write the shift as one substitution. $\hbar k_\mu\mapsto\pi_\mu=\hbar k_\mu+ϙ A_\mu$. Every formula of the limit is then the free formula with $\pi$ in place of $\hbar k$, and the only new object is the curvature.
Family 3: The Klein–Gordon Equation, Free
What the Seven Carry
| article | what it carries for the limit | worth |
|---|---|---|
| The Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the exact pair with $Q$: $E^{2}/c^{2}-\lvert\vec p\rvert^{2}=m^{2}c^{2}+2mQ$, the reduction to the WKB pair, the current and the two sheets | the limit's whole content |
| The Fourier Transform and the Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | $Q$ measured on the amplitude's shape: $0.000$, $0.999$, $3.775$ and $1155.53$; the quantum potential measures curvature and a symbol needs flatness | the error, quantified |
| The Lagrangian and the Klein–Gordon Equation in Polar Variables | the chart action with the frame metric $g_{ab}$, the $\cosh$/$\sinh$ structure, the regular Legendre transform | the limit from the action |
| The Fourier Transform and the Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol is a scalar, $k^{2}-k_m^{2}$; a symbol exists only for a constant amplitude | the approximation's structure |
| The Lagrangian and the Klein–Gordon Equation in Momentum Space | the form at a mode and its two roots | the action at a mode |
| The Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the equation, the dispersion, the current | precondition |
| The Lagrangian and the Klein–Gordon Equation | the action and its currents | precondition |
The Verdict
The polar article is the family's limit article, and it gives more than the Schrödinger one. The second-order equation supplies a mass shell, so the eikonal is a dispersion and not only a Hamilton–Jacobi equation. The pair is exact, and the reduction to WKB is one substitution: the action dominated by its rest term $-mc\,r'_t$, and $\Box \varrho$ replaced by $\Delta \varrho$.
The Fourier polar article is the most useful in the family for the approximation. It prices the error on four shapes of amplitude. The value $1155.53$ for a narrow Gaussian is the reason the limit is a statement about a state and not about a system.
The variational polar article supplies the metric. The frame's $\cosh$ multiplies all four squares and the $\sinh$ multiplies two cross terms, so the chart's principal symbol is a quadratic form and not the identity. That is the chart form of the polarization statement.
How the Formulas Go
Substitute the central word into the squared equation.
$$ \left(\Box_\Phi-k_m^{2}\right)\Xi_t=0 , \qquad \Xi_t=\varrho\,e^{iS/\hbar}\,\varepsilon e_t . $$
The pair, exact.
$$ \left(\frac{\partial S}{\partial r'_t}\right)^{2}-|\nabla S|^{2}=m^{2}c^{2}-\hbar^{2}\frac{\Box_\Phi \varrho}{r} , \qquad \nabla\cdot\left(\rho_{\mathrm{num}}\nabla S\right)-\frac{\partial}{\partial r'_t}\left(\rho_{\mathrm{num}}\frac{\partial S}{\partial r'_t}\right)=0 . $$
The eikonal is the mass shell, and the error is the same bracketed term. In momentum variables,
$$ \frac{E^{2}}{c^{2}}-|\vec p|^{2}=m^{2}c^{2}+2mQ , $$
so the truncation is a shift of the mass shell by the quantum potential, and the relative size is $\epsilon^{2}$ as in the Schrödinger case.
Write the sign of the energy as a sheet and not as a square root. The mass shell is a two-sheeted hyperboloid here, so the eikonal determines $E$ up to a sign and the charge density changes sign with the energy. A limit that writes $E=c\sqrt{\vec p^{2}+m^{2}c^{2}}$ has chosen a sheet.
Family 4: The Klein–Gordon Equation, Coupled
What the Seven Carry
| article | what it carries for the limit | worth |
|---|---|---|
| The Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the covariant pair with $Q$ unchanged, the kinetic momentum, the gauge-invariant current, the vorticity $ϙ\vec B$, the circulation $2\pi\hbar n+ϙ\Phi_B$ | the limit's whole content |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Polar Variables | the chart action with the covariant brackets | the limit from the action |
| The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol at $\pi$ | the limit's symbol |
| The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the symbol's chart reading | the approximation's reading |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Momentum Space | the form at a mode | the action at a mode |
| The Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the equation and covariance | precondition |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Klein–Gordon Equation | the action and its currents | precondition |
The Verdict
The coupled polar article is the family's best article for the limit, for one reason that the other families do not have. It carries a topological statement: the circulation is $2\pi\hbar n+ϙ\Phi_B$. That is a ray-level result — the phase's integral around a loop — and it is the sharpest thing any of the fifty-six articles says about what the limit retains that the free theory does not.
The covariant pair is the free pair with two substitutions, as in the Schrödinger case, and the quantum potential is untouched.
One limit of the chart is stated and worth repeating. The chart carries the component equation and cannot carry the algebra's equation when the field strength is nonzero, because the curvature term is a general element after conjugation by the field. A limit taken in the chart is a limit of the component equation, and that restriction is the chart's and not the limit's.
How the Formulas Go
The covariant derivative factors on a central field.
$$ \tilde\nabla_{\mathrm{gco},\mu}\left(\varrho\,e^{iS/\hbar}e_t\right)=e^{iS/\hbar}\left(\partial_\mu \varrho+i \varrho\kappa^{\mathrm{kin}}_\mu\right)e_t , $$
so the pair is the free pair with $\pi$.
$$ \left(\partial_{r'_t}S-ϙ a'_t\right)^{2}-\left|\nabla S+ϙ\vec A\right|^{2}=m^{2}c^{2}-\hbar^{2}\frac{\Box_\Phi \varrho}{r} , $$
$$ \nabla\cdot\left(\rho_{\mathrm{num}}\left(\nabla S+ϙ\vec A\right)\right)-\frac{\partial}{\partial r'_t}\left(\rho_{\mathrm{num}}\left(\partial_{r'_t}S-ϙ a'_t\right)\right)=0 . $$
Then take the loop integral, and that is the step the free family cannot take.
$$ \oint\vec\pi\cdot d\vec r=2\pi\hbar\,n+ϙ\Phi_B . $$
Write the vorticity as the field strength. $\nabla\times\vec\pi=ϙ\vec B$, so a rotation of the ray is a magnetic field and nothing else.
Family 5: The Dirac Equation, Free
What the Seven Carry
| article | what it carries for the limit | worth |
|---|---|---|
| The Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the four brackets — scale, phase, boost connection, rotor connection — as continuity, guidance, velocity transport and spin transport; $\tilde K_{\Phi}=\tilde\nabla_\Phi\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}$; the velocity $\tilde V_{\Phi}=ic\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}^{-2}$; the mass shell as frame unitarity $\tilde K_{\Phi}\tilde K_{\Phi}^{\natural}=-k_m^{2}$ | the limit's exact form |
| The Lagrangian and the Dirac Equation in Polar Variables | the kinetic term in closed form, the four vanishing momenta, one second-class bracket | the limit's constraints |
| The Fourier Transform and the Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the transform of a phase is a place; no momentum-space function is the scale, the angle, the boost or the rotor | the approximation's limit |
| The Fourier Transform and the Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol is odd: $\lvert\sigma(-K)+\sigma(K)\rvert=2k_m$ | the approximation's structure |
| The Lagrangian and the Dirac Equation in Momentum Space | the second variation is one number, $N=\pi^{2}-k_m^{2}$, central because the $\natural$-square of any element is central | the action at a mode |
| The Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the chiral pair and its solutions | precondition |
| The Lagrangian and the Dirac Equation | the action and its currents | precondition |
The Verdict
The polar article carries the limit's equations and not the limit's ordering. The four brackets are exact and they are the fluid laws; the truncation to order $\epsilon^{0}$ plus transport is not performed in the article. That is not a defect of the article, because the ordering is performed in one companion outside these articles: Relativistic Mechanics from the Dirac Wave: The Non-Quantum Limit in Biquaternionic Form carries the free and the coupled eikonal, the mass shell, the velocity and the Lorentz force, and The Lagrangian and the Non-Quantum Limit: The Action Principle carries the stationary-phase principle that underlies the ordering.
The mass shell is the frame's unitarity, and that is the sharpest thing in the family. $\tilde K_{\Phi}\tilde K_{\Phi}^{\natural}=-k_m^{2}$ is one line, and it says that the dispersion is a property of a unit element and not a fourth equation.
The polar Fourier article states a bound that the other families do not state. The polar reading is a position-space reading: the transform of a phase is a place, so no momentum-space object is the scale, the angle, the boost or the rotor. A limit written in frequency space loses exactly the four brackets it needs.
This family is the one where the principal-symbol rule must be broken on purpose. The mass is not in the principal symbol. The squared or composed operator is the object to expand, and the corpus's pair does that by construction.
How the Formulas Go
Write the pair, then square it, then expand. The pair is
$$ \tilde\nabla_\Phi\tilde\Xi_R=k_m\tilde\Xi_L , \qquad \tilde\nabla_\Phi^{\natural}\tilde\Xi_L=k_m\tilde\Xi_R , $$
whose square is $(\Box_\Phi-k_m^{2})\tilde\Xi=0$. Expand the square, not the pair: that is what puts the mass at order zero.
The eikonal is the mass shell and the velocity is the boost, not the gradient's direction.
$$ \tilde K_{\Phi}=\tilde\nabla_\Phi\theta_{\mathrm{pha}} , \qquad \tilde V_{\Phi}=ic\,\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}^{-2}=\gamma\left(ic\,e_t+\vec v\right) , \qquad \tilde K_{\Phi}\tilde K_{\Phi}^{\natural}=-k_m^{2} . $$
The spin is the rotor and it is one order above the eikonal. The leading equation is central, so it commutes with the spin frame and cannot turn it. Write the spin transport at order one and say so:
$$ \vec s=\tilde u_{\mathrm r}\vec e_z\tilde u_{\mathrm r}^{\natural} , \qquad \tilde u_{\mathrm r}^{-1}\partial_{r'_t}\tilde u_{\mathrm r}=\tfrac12\vec\Omega_{\mathrm r} . $$
The spin's rate is the rotor's angular rate $\vec\Omega_{\mathrm r}$, the same object the variational companion names. The $g=2$ Larmor rate is that rate, and it is the subject of a separate article rather than of a display here.
One sentence to write, and it is the family's honest limit. The limit delivers the mass shell, the velocity and the transport; it does not deliver the spin, the chirality, the sign of the energy or the value of the charge.
Family 6: The Dirac Equation, Coupled
What the Seven Carry
| article | what it carries for the limit | worth |
|---|---|---|
| The Coupled Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | $\tilde K_{\Phi,\mathrm{gco}}=\tilde K_{\Phi}+\frac{ϙ}{\hbar}\tilde A_{\Phi}$; the mass shell as a translated hyperboloid of unchanged radius; the gauge transformation moves the angle and nothing else; the spin is gauge invariant | the limit's whole content |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Dirac Equation in Polar Variables | the chart action with one velocity; seven momenta vanishing or fixed; six constraints | the limit's constraints |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Dirac Equation in Momentum Space | the coupling's whole effect is a translation of the argument, residual zero; $N=\pi^{2}-k_m^{2}$; the curvature prevents centrality, so the mode form is exact only at zero field strength | the approximation's exactness |
| The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol at $\pi$ | the approximation's structure |
| The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the chart reading of the symbol | the approximation's reading |
| The Coupled Dirac Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the pair with a connection, covariance | precondition |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Dirac Equation | the action and its currents | precondition |
The Verdict
The coupled polar article is the strongest Dirac article for the limit. It states the covariant wave number in one line, states that the mass shell is translated and not deformed, and states that the invariant is the curvature. Those three sentences are the eikonal, the dispersion and the gauge structure of the limit.
Its honest limit is the spin. The connection cannot turn the rotor, and the spin's transport in a background is indirect, through the boost. The article says so rather than deriving it.
The triple is the article to consult for the approximation's exactness. The coupled symbol at a mode is the free one at $\tilde P'_{\Phi}$, and the composed operator is a central multiple of the identity exactly when the field strength vanishes. That is the precise statement of when the mode form is usable.
The variational polar article carries the count that matters for the transport. Seven momenta vanish or are fixed and six Euler–Lagrange equations are constraints. A limit that writes transport equations for all eight parameters is writing more equations than the system has.
How the Formulas Go
Substitute the covariant derivative, then read the shift off the phase bracket.
$$ \tilde\Xi^{-1}\tilde\nabla_{\mathrm{gco},\mu}\tilde\Xi=\tilde\Xi^{-1}\partial_\mu\tilde\Xi+\frac{iϙ}{\hbar}A_\mu , \qquad \tilde K_{\Phi,\mathrm{gco}}=\tilde K_{\Phi}+\frac{ϙ}{\hbar}\tilde A_{\Phi} . $$
The mass shell is the translated hyperboloid.
$$ \kappa_t^{2}-|\vec\kappa|^{2}=-k_m^{2} , \qquad \kappa_t=\frac{E+ϙ c a'_t}{\hbar c} , \qquad \vec\kappa=\frac{\vec p+ϙ\vec A}{\hbar} . $$
Then write the one sentence that separates this family from the scalar one. No constant potential opens a gap: the radius is $k_m$ at every $\tilde A_{\Phi}$, so a constant potential translates the hyperboloid and does not deform it.
And write the spin's status as a constraint on the claim. The rotor is invariant under the gauge group, so the phase rotation cannot reach it; the spin's precession in a background is one order above the eikonal and is not obtained in the chart.
Family 7: The Proca Equation, Free
What the Seven Carry
| article | what it carries for the limit | worth |
|---|---|---|
| The Fourier Transform and the Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol $\sigma=(k^{2}-k_m^{2})\delta-k^{\mu}k_{\nu}$, eigenvalues $\{k^{2}-k_m^{2},k^{2}-k_m^{2},k^{2}-k_m^{2},-k_m^{2}\}$, determinant $-k_m^{2}(k^{2}-k_m^{2})^{3}$; on shell rank one with a three-dimensional Lorenz kernel; the count $3-0=3$ against Maxwell's $3-1=2$ | the limit's ray content |
| The Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the two-branch word and its absence of a phase; the exact pair: a massive scale equation with a rapidity-gradient source, and $\partial_\mu(\varrho^{2}\partial_\mu\theta_{\mathrm{rpd}})=0$; the Lorenz condition as one divergence | the limit's obstruction |
| The Fourier Transform and the Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the symbol is even in the wave number, so it has no odd slot, so the chart has no guidance equation; the branch is not a spectral property | why the free limit cannot be written |
| The Lagrangian and the Proca Equation in Polar Variables | the chart Lagrangian, the mass term's sign as the branch, the Hessian of rank three with the scalar potential as null direction, the Lorenz condition as the secondary constraint | the limit's constrained structure |
| The Lagrangian and the Proca Equation in Momentum Space | the form at a mode; the longitudinal coefficient $\tfrac12k_m^{2}$ independent of momentum; the absent $\omega^{2}$ in the $A_0^{2}$ coefficient | the limit's constraint |
| The Proca Equation: Massive Spin One in Biquaternionic Form | the equation, the dispersion, three polarizations | partial: the dispersion and the count, but no ordering |
| The Lagrangian and the Proca Equation | the action, the Lorenz condition from the variation | precondition |
The Verdict
No article in this family can host the limit, and the polar article says why. The field is real, the word is a scale and a boost, the phase slot is empty. There is no amplitude against a phase gradient to compare. A reader looking for the non-quantum limit of the free Proca field in these seven will not find it, because it cannot be written.
What the family does carry is the ray content, and that is not nothing. The Fourier element article gives three polarizations from the kernel's dimension, the longitudinal eigenvalue $-k_m^{2}$, and the count that separates Proca from Maxwell. A limit of a vector field needs exactly that, and it is here.
The variational polar article carries the constrained structure. The Hessian has rank three, its null direction is the scalar potential at fixed vector potential, and the Lorenz condition is the secondary constraint. Four parameters, three physical. A limit that writes four independent rays is wrong by one.
The polar Fourier article carries the explanation. The symbol is even in the wave number, so it has no odd slot, so there is no phase bracket and no guidance equation. The absence is spectral and not accidental.
How the Formulas Go
Write the two branches, and do not write a phase.
$$ \tilde A_\Phi= \begin{cases} \varepsilon\,i\,\varrho\,\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}(\theta_{\mathrm{rpd}},\vec u_{\mathrm b}), & \langle\tilde A_\Phi\rangle_\natural=-\varrho^{2}<0,\\[2pt] \varrho\,\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}(\theta_{\mathrm{rpd}},\vec u), & \langle\tilde A_\Phi\rangle_\natural=+\varrho^{2}>0 . \end{cases} $$
The logarithmic derivative has no central bracket.
$$ \tilde A_\Phi^{-1}\partial_\mu\tilde A_\Phi=\partial_\mu\ln \varrho+\Gamma_\mu , \qquad \Gamma_\mu=\tilde U^{-1}\partial_\mu\tilde U , $$
and the pair that replaces Madelung's is
$$ \left(\Box_\Phi-k_m^{2}\right)\varrho+\varrho\sum_\mu\mathrm{Sc}\left(\Gamma_\mu^{2}\right)=0 , \qquad \sum_\mu\left(\partial_\mu\Gamma_\mu+\Gamma_\mu^{2}-\mathrm{Sc}\left(\Gamma_\mu^{2}\right)\right)+2\sum_\mu\partial_\mu\ln \varrho\,\Gamma_\mu=0 . $$
Then write the eikonal as a polarization problem and not as a phase equation. The symbol vanishes on the Lorenz plane,
$$ \left[\pi A\right]=0 , \qquad \det\sigma=\left(\pi^{2}-k_m^{2}\right)^{3}\left(-k_m^{2}\right) , $$
so on the shell three amplitudes are annihilated and the fourth is multiplied by $-k_m^{2}$. The eikonal is the dispersion; the polarization is the kernel; there is no transport equation for a scalar phase, because there is no scalar phase.
Write the frame curvature as the analogue of the quantum potential. The term $\sum_\mu\mathrm{Sc}(\Gamma_\mu^{2})$ plays the part that $\Box_\Phi \varrho/\varrho$ plays for a scalar. It is the term that a slow-frame expansion drops, and the article states its exact form.
Family 8: The Proca Equation, Coupled
What the Seven Carry
| article | what it carries for the limit | worth |
|---|---|---|
| The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the symbol is the free symbol's principal part at $\pi$ plus $\frac{iϙ}{\hbar}F$; the curvature is multiplication and carries no $\pi$, so it stays out of the principal symbol; the mass sign is the flag below | the limit's structure |
| The Fourier Transform and the Coupled Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the symbol's gauge-invariant content is its obstruction; the symbol is even in $\pi$, so the ray dispersion has no preferred sign | the limit's gauge structure |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Proca Equation in Momentum Space | the Legendre inversion is two-valued, roots reflected about $\omega=-ϙ c\varphi/\hbar$; the constraint $a'_t=\vec k_{\Phi}\cdot\vec a/k_t'$; the absent $\pi_t^{2}$ | the limit's ray facts |
| The Coupled Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Polar Variables | the four-factor word with a phase; the momentum shift $\hbar\kappa_\mu=p_\mu+ϙ A_\mu$; the gauge transformation as one coordinate's translation; the equation is second order with no primary constraint | the limit's precondition, then its word |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Proca Equation in Polar Variables | the action as a quadratic form in the eight gradients with a frame metric and mass potential $Rr^{2}$ | the limit's principal symbol in the chart |
| The Coupled Proca Equation in Biquaternionic Form | the complex carrier, the covariant Lorenz condition, the two currents | the limit's precondition |
| The Lagrangian and the Coupled Proca Equation | the mass term's exact invariance, the current, the field term's open normalization | precondition |
The Verdict
This is the family where the coupling enables the limit. The free field has no phase; the coupled field has one, and the phase is the charge. So the statements that matter are in the coupled articles, and the ordering of the family is the reverse of the other three.
The Fourier element article carries the theorem. The curvature term is a multiplication operator. It carries no $\pi$, so it cannot enter the principal symbol, so the eikonal is the free eikonal at $\pi$ and the curvature enters one order later. That is the limit and the approximation separated by the algebra, before any expansion is written.
The triple carries the ray facts in closed form. Two roots reflected about $\omega=-ϙ c\varphi/\hbar$; the constraint $a'_t=\vec k_{\Phi}\cdot\vec a/k_t'$; the absent $\pi_t^{2}$. The first is the two-branch ray Hamiltonian with the classical energy shift. The second says the longitudinal amplitude has no independent ray. The third is the primary constraint.
The polar equation article carries the word, and the word is the limit's ansatz. Its four factors are the amplitude, the phase, the boost and the rotor; the central brackets are the scale and the phase; the connection merges with them and cannot reach the frame. A limit written in this word has two orders and two frame constraints.
The variational polar article carries a warning it states itself. The Hessian's regularity is open. If the chart's principal symbol degenerates, the eikonal is a constraint and not a dispersion, and the limit changes character. That question has to be settled before a full spin-one limit is written.
How the Formulas Go
Write the word with the phase, and count eight against eight.
$$ \tilde A=\varrho\,e^{i\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}}\,\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}\left(\theta_{\mathrm{rpd}},\vec u_{\mathrm b}\right)\tilde u_{\mathrm r}\left(\theta_{\mathrm{axr}},\vec u_{\mathrm r}\right) , \qquad \langle\tilde A\rangle_\natural=\varrho^{2}e^{2i\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}} . $$
The momentum shift is one substitution.
$$ \hbar c\,\kappa_t=E+ϙ c\,a'_t , \qquad \hbar\vec\kappa=\vec p+ϙ\vec A , \qquad \pi_\mu=\hbar k_\mu+ϙ A_\mu . $$
The eikonal is the free dispersion at $\pi$, and the curvature is the next order.
$$ \pi^{2}=k_m^{2} , \qquad \sigma_{\mathrm{gco}}(\pi)=\sigma_{\mathrm{free}}(\pi)+\frac{iϙ}{\hbar}F , \qquad \det\sigma_{\mathrm{free}}(\pi)=\left(\pi^{2}-k_m^{2}\right)^{3}\left(-k_m^{2}\right) . $$
Then write the two shell facts and the constraint.
$$ \left[\pi A\right]=0 , \qquad \sigma_{\mathrm{free}}(\pi)\,\pi=-k_m^{2}\,\pi , \qquad a'_t=\frac{\vec k_{\Phi}\cdot\vec a}{k_t'} . $$
The first is the Lorenz plane, the second says the wave number is multiplied and not annihilated, the third is the primary constraint.
Write the gauge statement last, because it is the sentence the limit needs. The gauge transformation moves $\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}$ and nothing else, so the ray's phase is not observable, the kinetic momentum is, and the invariant is the field strength.
The Cross-Family Ledger
| family | eikonal | transport | error | can host the limit? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Schrödinger free | polar article: Hamilton–Jacobi with $V$, no mass shell | polar article: continuity, untouched by the truncation | variational polar; the amplitude is the WKB article's | yes, and it is done |
| Schrödinger coupled | coupled polar: kinetic momentum, potential energy | coupled polar | Fourier polar: the symbol fails for a chirped connection, one mode to twenty-seven | yes, and it is done |
| Klein–Gordon free | polar article: mass shell plus $2mQ$ | polar article | Fourier polar: $0.000$ to $1155.53$ over four shapes | yes |
| Klein–Gordon coupled | coupled polar: mass shell at $\pi$, plus the circulation quantum | coupled polar | not priced in the family | yes |
| Dirac free | polar article: the mass shell as frame unitarity, at the square | polar article: four brackets, spin included | not an equation here; the amplitude is the WKB article's | yes, through the square |
| Dirac coupled | coupled polar: translated hyperboloid, curvature the invariant | variational polar: six constraints; the rate is The Classical Origin of $g=2$'s | triple: exact only at zero field strength | yes |
| Proca free | Fourier element: three polarizations from the kernel | none, and the polar Fourier article says why | variational polar: the frame curvature | no, and the polar article says why |
| Proca coupled | Fourier element: free eikonal at $\pi$ | polar equation: the eight-parameter word | variational polar: the Hessian's regularity is open | yes, and it is not yet done |
Flagged Items
One display does not reduce to its companions. The free Proca Fourier article gives $\sigma=(k^{2}-k_m^{2})\delta^{\mu}{}_{\nu}-k^{\mu}k_{\nu}$, with eigenvalues $\{k^{2}-k_m^{2},k^{2}-k_m^{2},k^{2}-k_m^{2},-k_m^{2}\}$. The coupled Proca Fourier article gives $\sigma_{\mathrm{gco}}=(-\pi^{2}-k_m^{2})\delta^{\mu}{}_{\nu}+\frac{iϙ}{\hbar}F^{\mu}{}_{\nu}-\pi^{\mu}\pi_{\nu}$. Setting $F=0$ and $\pi=k$, the first bracket is $-(k^{2}+k_m^{2})$, where the free article has $k^{2}-k_m^{2}$. The mass term is $-k_m^{2}$ in both, so the discrepancy is not a sign of the mass. The quadratic term carries opposite signs, and that difference decides where the zeros lie. Recomputed at $k_m=0.7$ and $k^{2}=0.45$: the free symbol has eigenvalues $\{-0.04,-0.04,-0.04,-0.49\}$, which is $\{k^{2}-k_m^{2}\}$ three times and $-k_m^{2}$ once, and the coupled display has $\{-0.94,-0.94,-0.94,-1.39\}$, which is $\{-(\pi^{2}+k_m^{2})\}$ three times and $-(2\pi^{2}+k_m^{2})$ once. On the shell, at $k^{2}=k_m^{2}=0.49$, the free symbol has $\{0,0,0,-0.49\}$ and the coupled display has $\{-0.98,-0.98,-0.98,-1.47\}$. The first has three zeros and the second has none, so the coupled display cannot carry the mass shell it claims. The coupled article's own shell sentence, $\pi^{2}=k_m^{2}$, is the convention in which its display is being read, and against that sentence the display fails. Its own summary states that at a constant connection the symbol is $-\pi^{2}$ times the identity, which its display does not give either. One of the two displays is to be corrected, and the choice is the author's. The audit records the discrepancy and does not patch it.
The spin-one limit is not written. The corpus has the spin-zero limit in The Non-Quantum Limit of the Free Schrödinger Equation, The Non-Quantum Limit of the Coupled Schrödinger Equation and The Charged Schrödinger Fluid, and the spin-half limit in Relativistic Mechanics from the Dirac Wave. The spin-one limit exists as raw material in the coupled Proca Fourier pair, in the polar equation article and in the triple, and no article assembles it.
The mass-order rule had no home in the eight families. The corpus applies it correctly — the Dirac limit is taken on the square — but no article of the eight said that a first-order equation puts its mass below the derivative and therefore must be squared before the eikonal is read. Section How the Formulas Are Written stated it in this audit, which was the wrong place; it now sits in The Non-Quantum Limit of the Biquaternion Model, under the heading The Mass Sits Below the Derivative, with the rule and its check in one place.
Two charts have an open Hessian question. The coupled Proca variational polar article records it, and the coupled Dirac variational polar article records the parallel one for its six constraints. Both matter for the limit, because a degenerate principal symbol turns the eikonal into a constraint.
Summary
The definitions. The non-quantum limit is the regime $\epsilon=1/(k_{\Phi}L)\to0$ applied to a solution written as an amplitude and a phase; it takes a wave to its rays, it does not commute with superposition, and it does not act on the algebra. The non-quantum approximation is the series in $\epsilon$ cut at a stated order: the eikonal at order zero, the transport at order one, the quantum potential at order two.
The rule of writing. Only derivatives carry $\epsilon$. Coefficients do not, and the mass is the coefficient $\mu=k_m/k_{\Phi}$ and is never expanded. For a second-order operator the mass sits at order zero and the eikonal is the massive dispersion. For a first-order operator the mass sits below the derivative, so the operator is squared first. For a constrained field the zero set of the determinant is necessary and not sufficient, and the polarization condition has to be written.
The ranking. The Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon families carry their limits in the polar articles, and the Schrödinger one is already complete outside these articles. The Dirac family carries the exact form of the limit's equations in the polar article and the limit itself in one companion, Relativistic Mechanics from the Dirac Wave. The free Proca family cannot host the limit at all, and its polar article says why; its Fourier element article carries the three polarizations and its variational polar article the rank-three constraint, which is what a vector limit needs.
The inversion of the Proca family. The coupling creates the phase, so the coupled Proca articles carry what the free ones cannot. The Fourier element article separates the limit from the approximation by one observation: the curvature is a multiplication operator and cannot enter the principal symbol.
What the audit adds. A ranking of fifty-six articles by what they carry; the statement of the mass-order rule; the identification of the free Proca obstruction as a definitional one; and one flagged inconsistency between two symbol displays, left for the author.
Summary of Notation
| symbol | meaning |
|---|---|
| $\epsilon=1/(k_{\Phi}L)$ | the parameter of the non-quantum limit |
| $L$ | the length over which the amplitude varies; from the state, not from the algebra |
| $k_{\Phi}=\lvert\vec p\rvert/\hbar$, $k_m=mc/\hbar$, $k_t'=E/(\hbar c)$ | the three wave numbers |
| $\mu=k_m/k_{\Phi}=1/(\gamma\beta)$ | the coefficient of the mass; a parameter, never an order in $\epsilon$ |
| $\theta_{\mathrm{pha}}=S/\hbar$ | the phase in radians |
| $A$, $\varrho$ | the amplitude, real and positive |
| $\tilde U_{\Psi,\mathrm b}$, $\tilde u_{\mathrm r}$ | the Hermitian boost and the rotor of the word |
| $\pi_\mu=\hbar k_\mu+ϙ A_\mu$ | the shifted wave number; the kinetic momentum over $\hbar$ |
| $\sigma(\pi)$ | the symbol; the principal part at leading order |
| $Q$ | the quantum potential; the term the limit drops, of relative size $\epsilon^{2}$ |
| $\rho=\lvert Q\rvert/(E-V)$ | the error of the approximation |
| $\Gamma_\mu=\tilde U^{-1}\partial_\mu\tilde U$ | the Proca frame connection; the analogue of the phase bracket |
| $3-0=3$, $3-1=2$ | the kernel's dimension minus the gauge orbit's: three Proca polarizations against two for Maxwell |
Further Reading
- Michael V. Berry and K. E. Mount, "Semiclassical approximations in wave mechanics," Reports on Progress in Physics 35 (1972) 315–397, for the uniform approximations and the failure at caustics.
- Robert G. Littlejohn, "The semiclassical evolution of wave packets," Physics Reports 138 (1986) 193–291, for the error estimates and the spin transport at subleading order.
- V. P. Maslov and M. V. Fedoriuk, Semiclassical Approximation in Quantum Mechanics (Reidel, 1981), for the Lagrangian manifold and for the ray as a characteristic.
- Peter R. Holland, The Quantum Theory of Motion (Cambridge University Press, 1993), for the quantum potential and for the Bohm rewriting of the exact pair.
- Alfredo M. Ozorio de Almeida, Hamiltonian Systems: Chaos and Quantization (Cambridge University Press, 1988), chapter 2, for the classical limit and the failure of superposition.