The Modules and the Minimal Left Ideals of $M_5(\mathbb{C})$
Introduction
The algebra $M_5(\mathbb{C})$ acts on the carrier $V=\mathbb{C}^5$ by matrix multiplication. The carrier is the simple left module: it has no nonzero proper submodule, and every simple left module of $M_5$ is isomorphic to it. The minimal left ideals are the subspaces
$$ L=M_5P,\qquad P\text{ a rank-one idempotent}, $$
each of dimension $5$ and isomorphic to $V$. The five column ideals $M_5E_{11},\dots,M_5E_{55}$ are the minimal left ideals of a frame, and the left regular module decomposes as
$$ M_5=M_5E_{11}\oplus\cdots\oplus M_5E_{55}\cong V^{\oplus5}. $$
The Peirce lines $A_{kl}=P_kM_5P_l$ are one-dimensional subspaces, not modules: the left ideal generated by a line $A_{kl}$ is the whole column $M_5P_l$, of dimension $5$, and the right ideal is the row $P_kM_5$. A minimal left ideal is not a Peirce line, and a Peirce line is not a module. This is the precise distinction that the Peirce decomposition and the module theory require.
The double centralizer is the algebra itself: the commutant of $M_5$ in $\operatorname{End}_\mathbb{C}(V)$ is $\mathbb{C}I$, and the bicommutant is $M_5$. The algebra is semisimple, and every left module is a direct sum of copies of $V$; the right modules are the dual picture, with $V^*$ in place of $V$.
The article assumes the matrix algebra, the frame and the Peirce decomposition. It uses no form and no topology. The carrier is the highest-weight-$2$ module of the principal $\mathfrak{sl}_2$; there are no spinors at $n=5$, and the word spinor is not used for the carrier or for a minimal left ideal. The biquaternion case $n=2$ is the comparison: there the minimal left ideal is two-dimensional and is the spinor.
Modules over the Algebra
Left, Right and Bimodules
Definition. A left module over $M_5$ is a complex vector space $W$ with a bilinear map $M_5\times W\to W$, $(A,w)\mapsto Aw$, such that $(AB)w=A(Bw)$ and $Iw=w$. A right module is the same with the action on the right, $w(AB)=(wA)B$; a bimodule has both actions, and they commute.
Proposition. The carrier $V=\mathbb{C}^5$ is a left module by matrix multiplication, and the dual $V^*$ is a right module by $(v^*A)(v)=v^*(Av)$; equivalently, $V^*$ is a left module by $A\cdot v^*=v^*A^*$ with the transpose, but the natural structure is the right module.
Proof. The associativity of matrix multiplication gives the module axioms; the dual action is the transpose action, $(A^{\mathsf T}v^*)(v)=v^*(Av)$, and it is a right action because $(AB)^{\mathsf T}=B^{\mathsf T}A^{\mathsf T}$.
Corollary. $M_5$ itself is a left module over itself by left multiplication, a right module by right multiplication, and a bimodule with both. The algebra is the left regular module and the right regular module.
Proof. The axioms are the associativity and the unit of the algebra.
The Simple Module
Definition. A module is simple if it is nonzero and has no nonzero proper submodule.
Theorem. The carrier $V$ is a simple left module.
Proof. Let $0\ne W\subseteq V$ be a submodule and let $0\ne v\in W$. Some coordinate $v_j$ is nonzero. For every $i$, $E_{ij}v=v_je_i$, so $e_i\in W$ because $W$ is invariant under $E_{ij}$. Hence $W$ contains the standard basis and $W=V$.
Corollary. Every nonzero vector of $V$ generates $V$ as a left module. The annihilator of $V$ is zero: the action of $M_5$ on $V$ is faithful.
Proof. The first statement is the proof above; the second is that $Av=0$ for all $v$ implies $A=0$.
Semisimplicity
Theorem. The algebra $M_5(\mathbb{C})$ is semisimple: every left module is a direct sum of simple modules, and every submodule is a direct summand.
Proof. The algebra is a full matrix algebra over the semisimple algebra $\mathbb{C}$; by the Artin–Wedderburn theorem it is semisimple. Equivalently, the left regular module decomposes into the five minimal left ideals $M_5E_{jj}$, and every module is a quotient of a free module, hence a direct sum of copies of $V$ by the theory of semisimple rings.
Corollary. Every left module is isomorphic to $V^{\oplus m}$ for a unique $m$, and every simple left module is isomorphic to $V$.
Proof. A semisimple module is a direct sum of simple modules; the simple modules are the quotients of the regular module by maximal left ideals, and all are isomorphic to $V$ by the minimal-left-ideal computation below. The multiplicity $m$ is the dimension divided by $5$.
The Polarized Module of the Biquaternion Algebra
Rank-One Idempotents
Definition. A rank-one idempotent is a matrix $P$ with $P^2=P$ and $\operatorname{rank}P=1$.
Proposition. Every rank-one idempotent has the form
$$ P=v\ell,\qquad 0\ne v\in V,\quad 0\ne\ell\in V^*,\quad \ell(v)=1, $$
where $v\ell$ is the matrix $w\mapsto\ell(w)v$. Conversely every such pair gives a rank-one idempotent.
Proof. The image of $P$ is a line $\mathbb{C}v$; choose $v$ spanning it. Since $P$ is the identity on its image, $Pv=v$. Define $\ell(w)$ by $Pw=\ell(w)v$; then $\ell$ is linear, $\ell(v)=1$, and $P= v\ell$. Conversely $(v\ell)(v\ell)=v\ell(v)\ell=v\ell$.
Corollary. The diagonal matrix units $E_{jj}=e_je_j^{\vee}$ are rank-one idempotents; the spectral projectors $P_k$ are rank-one idempotents of the root, with $P_k=v_k\ell_k$ for a vector $v_k$ spanning the spectral line and a dual functional $\ell_k$.
Proof. $E_{jj}$ has image $\mathbb{C}e_j$ and functional $e_j^{\vee}$; the spectral projector has the spectral line as image and the left eigenfunctional as $\ell_k$.
The Ideals $M_5P$
Theorem. For a rank-one idempotent $P$, the left ideal $M_5P$ is minimal, of dimension $5$, and is isomorphic to $V$ as a left module via
$$ M_5P\longrightarrow V,\qquad A\longmapsto Av, $$
where $v$ spans the image of $P$.
Proof. For $P=v\ell$ with $\ell(v)=1$, the ideal $M_5P$ consists of the matrices $A=BP=Bv\,\ell=w\ell$ with $w=Bv\in V$; it is five-dimensional, because $w$ is free. The map $A\mapsto Av=w$ is left $M_5$-linear and surjective, and its kernel on $M_5P$ is zero: $A=w\ell$ and $Av=w$, so $Av=0$ gives $w=0$ and $A=0$. It is therefore an isomorphism onto $V$. For minimality, let $0\ne A=w\ell\in M_5P$ with $w\ne0$; choose $B$ with $Bw=v$; then $BA=Bw\,\ell=v\ell=P$, so $P\in M_5A$ and $M_5P\subseteq M_5A$. Hence $M_5A=M_5P$, and $M_5P$ is simple.
Corollary. Every minimal left ideal is of the form $M_5P$ for a rank-one idempotent $P$, and every minimal left ideal is isomorphic to $V$. The minimal left ideals are the simple submodules of the left regular module.
Proof. By the standard structure theorem for full matrix algebras, every minimal left ideal is $M_5P$ for an idempotent $P$ (see Pierce, Associative Algebras). The idempotent can be chosen of rank one: if $\operatorname{rank}P=r$, then $M_5P$ consists of the matrices that vanish on $\ker P$, equivalently $A=AP$, and it has dimension $5r$; minimality forces $r=1$. The theorem above then gives the isomorphism with $V$.
The Column Ideals
Proposition. For the diagonal idempotents $E_{jj}$,
$$ M_5E_{jj}=\{A:A\text{ has nonzero entries only in column }j\}, $$
the $j$-th column ideal, of dimension $5$. The left regular module decomposes as
$$ M_5=M_5E_{11}\oplus\cdots\oplus M_5E_{55}\cong V^{\oplus5}. $$
Proof. $AE_{jj}$ has the $j$-th column of $A$ and zeros elsewhere; the column ideals are in direct sum and exhaust $M_5$. Each is isomorphic to $V$ by the theorem, so the sum is $V^{\oplus5}$; the dimension is $5\cdot5=25$.
Corollary. The five column ideals are minimal left ideals, and their sum is the whole algebra. A left ideal need not be a two-sided ideal: the column ideals are left ideals but not right ideals, and the algebra is simple as a two-sided algebra.
Proof. $M_5E_{jj}$ is a left ideal; it is not a right ideal because $E_{jj}M_5$ is the row ideal, not the column. The two-sided ideals are only $0$ and $M_5$ by the simplicity theorem.
The Peirce Lines Are Not Modules
Theorem. The Peirce line $A_{kl}=P_kM_5P_l$ is one-dimensional and is not a left or right module over $M_5$ (unless $k=l$ and the algebra is one-dimensional, which it is not). The left ideal generated by $A_{kl}$ is the column $M_5P_l$, of dimension $5$; the right ideal is the row $P_kM_5$, of dimension $5$.
Proof. $A_{kl}$ is spanned by $E_{kl}$ (in the spectral frame). The left multiplication $M_5A_{kl}=M_5P_kM_5P_l=M_5P_l$ because $M_5P_kM_5=M_5$ (the algebra is simple and $P_k\ne0$); this is the whole column, of dimension $5$, not the line. The right multiplication is the row. A one-dimensional subspace stable under the whole algebra would be a one-dimensional module, but the simple module has dimension $5$.
Corollary. The Peirce decomposition
$$ M_5=\bigoplus_{k,l}A_{kl} $$
is a decomposition into lines, not into modules. The minimal left ideals are the sums of the lines by columns,
$$ M_5P_l=\bigoplus_{k}A_{kl}, $$
and the minimal right ideals are the sums by rows,
$$ P_kM_5=\bigoplus_{l}A_{kl}. $$
Proof. The lines are the intersections $P_kM_5P_l$; the column is the sum over $k$ for fixed $l$; the row is the sum over $l$ for fixed $k$.
Remark. The Peirce line and the minimal left ideal must not be identified. The line is one-dimensional and is not a module; the ideal is five-dimensional and is the simple module. The biquaternion article uses the columns as the minimal left ideals; in $M_5$ the columns are the five-dimensional ideals $M_5P_l$, and the lines inside them are the Peirce lines. The word spinor is not attached to either: the simple module is the carrier, of highest weight $2$.
The Peirce Carrier
Definition. The left Peirce carrier of a rank-one idempotent $P$ is the left ideal $C_L(P)=M_5P$; the right Peirce carrier is the right ideal $C_R(P)=PM_5$. With $Q=I-P$, the Peirce decomposition reads
$$ C_L(P)=PM_5P\oplus QM_5P,\qquad C_R(P)=PM_5P\oplus PM_5Q, $$
with summands of dimensions $1$, $4$, $4$, so that both carriers have dimension $1+4=5$.
Proposition. The left carrier is isomorphic to $V$ as a left module, the right carrier to $V^*$ as a right module. For a spectral projector $P=P_k$, $C_L(P_k)=\bigoplus_lA_{lk}$ is the $k$-th column and $C_R(P_k)=\bigoplus_lA_{kl}$ is the $k$-th row.
Proof. The two decompositions are the Peirce decomposition read on the left and on the right. The dimensions are $\dim PM_5P=1$ and $\dim QM_5P=\dim PM_5Q=4$. The isomorphism $M_5P\cong V$ is the theorem of §The Ideals $M_5P$; for the right carrier, $PM_5=\{v\varphi:\varphi\in V^*\}$ and $v\varphi\mapsto\varphi$ is an isomorphism onto $V^*$. For the spectral projector, $A_{lk}=P_lM_5P_k$ and the column is the sum over $l$; the row is the sum over $l$ of $A_{kl}$.
Remark. The formula $PM_5P\oplus PM_5Q$ is the right carrier; the left carrier is $PM_5P\oplus QM_5P$. The two mixed corners are exchanged by transposition and by the involution, and they are different subspaces of $M_5$. The left carrier is the module $V$; the right carrier is the dual right module $V^*$. Neither is a Peirce line, and neither is a spinor.
The Double Centralizer
The Commutant
Theorem. The commutant of $M_5(\mathbb{C})$ in $\operatorname{End}_\mathbb{C}(V)$ is the scalars:
$$ \{T\in\operatorname{End}_\mathbb{C}(V):TA=AT\text{ for all }A\in M_5\}=\mathbb{C}I . $$
Proof. It suffices to commute with the matrix units $E_{ij}$. The identity $TE_{ij}=E_{ij}T$ in entries gives $T_{ki}\delta_{jl}=\delta_{ki}T_{jl}$; choosing $k=i$ and $l\ne j$ gives $T_{il}=0$ for $i\ne l$? Let us do it directly: $TE_{ij}$ has the $i$-th column of $T$ in column $j$; $E_{ij}T$ has the $j$-th row of $T$ in row $i$. Comparing the $(a,b)$ entries, $T_{ai}\delta_{bj}=\delta_{ai}T_{jb}$. For $a=i,b=j$: $T_{ii}=T_{jj}$; for $a\ne i,b=j$: $T_{ai}=0$. As $i,j$ vary, $T$ is diagonal with all diagonal entries equal. Hence $T=\lambda I$.
Corollary. Every $M_5$-linear endomorphism of $V$ is scalar; by Schur's lemma this is the statement that $V$ is simple, and the scalar is the unique intertwiner.
Proof. An intertwiner is an element of the commutant; the commutant is $\mathbb{C}I$.
The Bicommutant
Theorem. The bicommutant of $M_5$ is $M_5$:
$$ \{T\in\operatorname{End}_\mathbb{C}(V):TS=ST\text{ for all }S\in M_5\}=M_5 . $$
Proof. The bicommutant contains $M_5$ because every element of $M_5$ commutes with every element of $M_5$. Conversely, the commutant of $M_5$ is $\mathbb{C}I$, and the commutant of $\mathbb{C}I$ is all of $\operatorname{End}_\mathbb{C}(V)=M_5$; so the bicommutant is $M_5$. This is the double centralizer theorem for a full matrix algebra.
Corollary. The algebra is its own bicommutant, and the pair $(M_5,V)$ is a central simple algebra with its simple module. The algebra is isomorphic to $\operatorname{End}_\mathbb{C}(V)$.
Proof. The natural map $M_5\to\operatorname{End}_\mathbb{C}(V)$ is injective (the action is faithful) and both spaces have dimension $25$, so it is an isomorphism; the bicommutant is the algebra.
Remark. The double centralizer is the algebraic form of the statement that the only operators commuting with all matrices are scalars. It is the reason the module $V$ has no extra structure: an $M_5$-linear map is scalar, and the endomorphism algebra of $V$ is the whole matrix algebra. The same statement in the biquaternion case gives the quaternion structure on the spinor; in $M_5$ it gives only the scalars.
The Classification
Every Module Is a Direct Sum of Copies of $V$
Theorem. Every left $M_5$-module is isomorphic to $V^{\oplus m}$ for a unique $m\ge0$. Every right module is isomorphic to $(V^*)^{\oplus m}$.
Proof. The algebra is semisimple, so every module is a direct sum of simple modules; every simple module is isomorphic to $V$ by the minimal-left-ideal theorem; the multiplicity is the dimension divided by $5$. The right case is the dual: the simple right module is $V^*$, and the right regular module is $(V^*)^{\oplus5}$.
Corollary. The left regular module is $V^{\oplus5}$, the right regular module is $(V^*)^{\oplus5}$, and the algebra as a bimodule is $V\otimes V^*$.
Proof. The column decomposition gives the left regular module; the row decomposition gives the right; the identification $M_5\cong V\otimes V^*$ sends $v\otimes\ell$ to $v\ell$, and the left and right actions are the two factors.
The Left Regular Module
Proposition. The left regular module has the decomposition
$$ M_5=\bigoplus_{j=1}^{5}M_5E_{jj}, $$
and each summand is a minimal left ideal isomorphic to $V$. The endomorphism ring of the left regular module is $M_{\mathrm{opp},5}\cong M_5$.
Proof. The column decomposition is the direct sum; each column is minimal and isomorphic to $V$; the endomorphisms of the left regular module are the right multiplications, which form the opposite algebra, isomorphic to $M_5$ by the transpose.
Corollary. The multiplicity of $V$ in the left regular module is $5$, and the dimension count is $5\cdot5=25$.
Proof. There are five column ideals, each isomorphic to $V$; the dimension is $5\cdot5$.
The Right Regular Module
Proposition. The right regular module has the decomposition
$$ M_5=\bigoplus_{k=1}^{5}E_{kk}M_5, $$
and each summand is a minimal right ideal isomorphic to $V^*$. The right regular module is $(V^*)^{\oplus5}$.
Proof. The row decomposition is the direct sum; each row is a minimal right ideal, dual to the column; the dimension is $5\cdot5=25$.
Corollary. The left and right regular modules are dual, and the bimodule $M_5$ is $V\otimes V^*$.
Proof. The dual of $V^{\oplus5}$ is $(V^*)^{\oplus5}$; the tensor product identification is the standard one.
The Biquaternion Comparison
The $M_2$ Case
For $n=2$, the algebra $M_2(\mathbb{C})\cong\mathbb{B}$ has a two-dimensional simple module, the spinor. The minimal left ideals are the column ideals $M_2E_{11}$ and $M_2E_{22}$, each of dimension $2$ and isomorphic to the spinor; the left regular module is $(\mathbb{C}^2)^{\oplus2}$. The Peirce lines are one-dimensional; the minimal left ideal is two-dimensional; the same distinction holds.
Proposition. The $M_2$ minimal left ideal $M_2P$ is two-dimensional and is the spinor of the biquaternion model. The commutant of $M_2$ is $\mathbb{C}I$, and the bicommutant is $M_2$.
Proof. The same proofs with $n=2$: the column has dimension $2$; the commutant is scalar; the bicommutant is the algebra.
No Spinors at $M_5$
Theorem. The simple module of $M_5$ is the carrier $V=\mathbb{C}^5$, of highest weight $2$. There is no spinor module at $n=5$: the carrier is the symmetric fourth power $\operatorname{sym}^4(\mathbb{C}^2)$, and its weights are the integers $2,1,0,-1,-2$.
Proof. The identification of the carrier with the symmetric power is the standard $\mathfrak{sl}_2$ computation; the weights are integers, so no half-integer weight occurs. The simple module is unique up to isomorphism and is $V$.
Corollary. The minimal left ideal of $M_5$ is five-dimensional and is isomorphic to the carrier; it is not a spinor, not a column of a matrix in the sense of an element, and not a Peirce line. The word spinor is reserved for the two-dimensional module of $M_2$.
Proof. The minimal left ideal is $M_5P\cong V$, of dimension $5$; the Peirce line is one-dimensional; the column is the space, not an element.
Remark. The biquaternion spinor and the $M_5$ carrier are different modules of different algebras. The first is the two-dimensional simple module of $M_2$; the second is the five-dimensional simple module of $M_5$, of highest weight $2$. The minimal left ideals are the modules in both cases, but the dimensions and the spin differ. The Peirce lines are one-dimensional in both cases, and they are not modules in either.
Summary
The carrier $V=\mathbb{C}^5$ is the simple left module of $M_5(\mathbb{C})$; every simple left module is isomorphic to $V$, and every left module is $V^{\oplus m}$. The minimal left ideals are the spaces $M_5P$ for rank-one idempotents $P$, of dimension $5$, isomorphic to $V$; the column ideals $M_5E_{jj}$ give the decomposition
$$ M_5=M_5E_{11}\oplus\cdots\oplus M_5E_{55}\cong V^{\oplus5}. $$
$$ \boxed{\ \text{The simple module is }V=\mathbb{C}^5\text{, of highest weight }2;\quad \text{the minimal left ideals are }M_5P\cong V;\quad \text{the Peirce lines are not modules.}\ } $$
The commutant of $M_5$ is $\mathbb{C}I$, the bicommutant is $M_5$, and the algebra is $\operatorname{End}_\mathbb{C}(V)$. The right modules are the dual picture, with $V^*$; the bimodule is $V\otimes V^*$. At $n=2$ the simple module is the two-dimensional spinor; at $n=5$ it is the five-dimensional carrier, and there are no spinors.
| Object | Dimension | Module? |
|---|---|---|
| Carrier $V$ | $5$ | Simple left module |
| Minimal left ideal $M_5P$ | $5$ | Isomorphic to $V$ |
| Column ideal $M_5E_{jj}$ | $5$ | Minimal left ideal |
| Row ideal $E_{kk}M_5$ | $5$ | Minimal right ideal |
| Peirce line $A_{kl}$ | $1$ | Not a module |
| Left regular module | $25$ | $V^{\oplus5}$ |
| Right regular module | $25$ | $(V^*)^{\oplus5}$ |
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $V=\mathbb{C}^5$ | The carrier, the simple left module |
| $V^*$ | The dual, the simple right module |
| $M_5P$ | The minimal left ideal of a rank-one idempotent $P$ |
| $M_5E_{jj}$ | The $j$-th column ideal |
| $E_{kk}M_5$ | The $k$-th row ideal |
| $A_{kl}=P_kM_5P_l$ | The Peirce line |
| $\operatorname{End}_{M_5}(V)$ | The commutant, equal to $\mathbb{C}I$ |
| $V\otimes V^*$ | The algebra as a bimodule |
Further Reading
- Richard S. Pierce, Associative Algebras (Springer, 1982), for the modules over a full matrix algebra, the minimal left ideals and the Peirce decomposition.
- Tsit-Yuen Lam, A First Course in Noncommutative Rings (Springer, second edition, 2001), for the Artin–Wedderburn theorem, the semisimple rings and the simple modules.
- Max-Albert Knus, Alexander Merkurjev, Markus Rost and Jean-Pierre Tignol, The Book of Involutions (American Mathematical Society, 1998), for the modules of a central simple algebra and the double centralizer.
- The Matrix Algebra $M_5(\mathbb{C})$, for the algebra and its simplicity.
- The Peirce Decomposition of $M_5(\mathbb{C})$, for the lines $A_{kl}$ and the distinction from the ideals.
- The Frame, the Simple Nilpotents and the Gauge of $M_5(\mathbb{C})$, for the column and row ideals of the frame.
- Peirce Decompositions of the Biquaternion Algebra, for the biquaternion minimal left ideals and the spinor.