The Slot and the Summand: $\tfrac12$ in $\mathbb{B}$ and $\tfrac32$ in the Operators

Introduction

The subject. The algebra has a module of label $\tfrac12$ and the operator algebra has a module of label $\tfrac32$. The two labels are the same object read at two levels: the operator module is the third symmetric power of the algebra module, and the label is the sum of three copies of $\tfrac12$. The article names the two readings, the slot and the summand, computes their dimensions, and shows that the doubling is an exact rule with no free parameter.

The order of the article. The two labels come first; the slot second. The summand follows, then the doubling, and the reading closes the article.

It assumes The Four Weights of the Module and the Half Angle, The Spin Group: the Principal Copy, $\operatorname{Sym}^{3}$ and the Kernel $\{\pm\mathrm I\}$ and The Minimal Left Ideals and the Module $V_{3/2}$. The row of the elements is the slot; the row of the operators is the summand.

The result in one line. The algebra is a slot of half-integer label $\tfrac12$ and dimension two, the operator algebra is a summand of label $\tfrac32$ and dimension four, and the passage is the symmetric cube, which multiplies the label by three.

Boundaries. The weights are The Four Weights of the Module and the Half Angle; the decomposition of the operator space is The Clebsch–Gordan Decomposition of the Operators; the identity of the two labels is also read in From the Spin Decomposition to the Weight Strings.

The Two Labels

Definition. The label of a simple module of the copy is the highest weight of its weight string; the module of the algebra has label $\tfrac12$ and the module of the operators has label $\tfrac32$.

Proof. The weight strings are $\tfrac12,-\tfrac12$ and $\tfrac32,\tfrac12,-\tfrac12,-\tfrac32$.

Corollary. The two labels differ by one unit, and the dimensions differ by a factor two.

Proof. $\tfrac32-\tfrac12=1$ and $4/2=2$.

Corollary. The two labels are both half-integer, so both modules are quaternionic.

Proof. The type is decided by the parity of twice the label, and both are odd.

The reading. Two labels, one half-integer each, and a difference of one. The article explains where the one comes from and why it cannot be anything else.

The Slot

Proposition. The algebra is a slot: its module is the two-dimensional spinor space, the label is $\tfrac12$, and the slot is the pair (label, dimension) $=(\tfrac12,2)$.

Proof. The algebra is four-dimensional over the reals and two-dimensional over the complex numbers; the copy acts on it by left multiplication, and the weights are $\pm\tfrac12$.

Corollary. The slot is the smallest non-trivial module of the group, and it is the module on which the sign after a full turn is visible.

Proof. The weights are half-integers, so the rotor of angle $2\pi$ acts as $-1$.

Corollary. The slot is quaternionic and has real dimension four.

Proof. The complex dimension two and the negative square of the intertwiner.

The reading. The slot is the elementary object: one label, one dimension, one sign. Every other module of the theory is built from it by symmetric powers and tensor products, and the operator module is the first non-trivial power.

The Summand

Proposition. The operator algebra is a summand: its module is the four-dimensional space of the operators, the label is $\tfrac32$, and the summand is $(\tfrac32,4)$.

Proof. The module of the operators is the algebra as a left module, of complex dimension four; the weights are the four half-integers from $\tfrac32$ down.

Corollary. The summand is the third symmetric power of the slot, $\tfrac32=3\cdot\tfrac12$.

Proof. The weights of the symmetric cube are the sums of three weights of the slot, the largest being three times $\tfrac12$.

Corollary. The summand is quaternionic, with real dimension eight.

Proof. The label is half-integer.

The reading. The summand is the slot cubed, and the cube is the reason for the label $\tfrac32$. Nothing in the definition of the operator algebra mentions the copy; the label appears only when the copy is chosen, and then it appears as three times the slot.

The Doubling

Theorem. The passage from the slot to the summand multiplies the label by three and the dimension by two, and no other passage preserves both the half-integer character and the symmetry of the strings.

Proof. The symmetric cube of a module of label $j$ has label $3j$; with $j=\tfrac12$ the label is $\tfrac32$. The dimension of the cube of a two-dimensional module is four. Any other power would give a label $kj$ with a different $k$, and the half-integer character would require $k$ odd.

Corollary. The next symmetric power, the fourth, would have label two and would be integral, so the string of the operator module stops at the cube because the algebra does.

Proof. The symmetric cube is the module of the operators, and there is no fourth symmetric power in the theory.

Corollary. The tensor square of the summand has the four integer labels, which is the spin decomposition of the operator space.

Proof. Twice $\tfrac32$ is three, and the series runs from zero to three.

The reading. The two operations, symmetric cube and tensor square, are the two passages of the theory: cube from the algebra to its operators, square from the operators to their algebra. The first doubles the label's denominator, the second removes it.

The Square and the Cube

Proposition. The algebra is the square of the slot and the module of the operators is its cube, and the two are different modules although both have dimension four.

Proof. The tensor square of a two-dimensional space has dimension four and splits as the triplet and the singlet; the third symmetric power of a two-dimensional space has dimension four and is irreducible, of label $\tfrac32$.

Corollary. The square of the slot contains the singlet, and the cube does not.

Proof. The square of the slot contains the alternating square of two slot vectors, which is one-dimensional and invariant; the cube has top weight $\tfrac32$ and every weight of it is half-integral, so no invariant line occurs in it.

Corollary. A statement about the algebra and a statement about the operators cannot be transferred by dimension alone, since the two spaces have the same dimension and different module structure.

Proof. The two decompositions $3+1$ and $4$.

The reading. The two spaces are twins of dimension four with different symmetry. The algebra keeps a singlet because it is a square, and the operators have none because they are a cube. This is the reason the operators carry the half-integer label and the algebra does not.

The Two Lattices

Definition. The lattice of labels is the set of the half-integers $0,\tfrac12,1,\tfrac32,2,\dots$, and for each member $j$ there is one simple module $V_j$, of dimension $2j+1$.

Proposition. The labels of the slot are $\tfrac12$ and the labels of the summand are $\tfrac32$; the first is half-integer and the second is an integer.

Proof. The algebra is a slot of dimension two, so $2j+1=2$ and $j=\tfrac12$; the operators are a summand of dimension four, so $j=\tfrac32$.

Corollary (which group carries which). The label $\tfrac12$ belongs to $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ and not to $\mathrm{SO}(3)$, and the label $\tfrac32$ belongs to $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ and not to $\mathrm{SO}(3)$ either; only the integer labels descend to the rotation group.

Proof. The group $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ is the sphere $S^3$ and the rotation group is its quotient by the antipodal pair; a label $j$ changes sign along the antipodal pair exactly when $j$ is a half-integer, so a half-integer label is not a representation of the quotient. The label $\tfrac32$ is a half-integer as well, although its dimension is even.

The reading. The doubling of the article multiplies the label by three, and it does not change the lattice: a half-integer remains half-integer. So the slot and the summand are both spin representations, and the passage between them stays inside the half-integer lattice. The two systems of the operator space are the two factors of the square, and the doubling is the passage from one system to the pair.

The Reading

One object, two names. The slot and the summand are the same module at two levels of one construction; the names record which level a statement belongs to. A statement about a spinor is a statement about the slot; a statement about an operator is a statement about the summand.

One arithmetic. The labels $\tfrac12$ and $\tfrac32$ differ by the number of factors in the cube, and the difference is the only thing the two rows do not share.

One warning. The label of the operator module is not the label of the algebra, and a formula that uses one where the other belongs will be off by a factor three in the exponent of a phase. The half angle is the place where the error shows first.

One check. The two dimensions, two and four, satisfy the binomial count of the symmetric cube, $\binom{2+3-1}{3}=4$, and the two labels satisfy the addition of three halves. The two identities are one identity read on dimensions and on weights.

Further Reading