The Spin-Two Carrier and the Rank Strata at $n=4$
Introduction
The subject. The elements of the carrier of label two have rank zero, two or four, and never one or three. The article proves it from the characteristic polynomial, exhibits the rank-two elements, and reads them as the isotropic cone of the trace form.
The order of the article. The first section proves the spectral rigidity. The second derives the three ranks and excludes one and three. The third exhibits the rank-two elements. The fourth computes the Jordan types and compares with the alternating square at order two. The fifth draws the boundary.
It assumes The Spin-Two Carrier and the Trace Form at $n=4$ and Introduction to the Spin-Two Carrier at $n=4$: the Alternating Square.
The result in one line. The rank of an element of $V_2$ is four when $\operatorname{tr}(X^{2})\neq0$, two when the trace of the square vanishes at a nonzero element, and zero at the origin; rank one and rank three are impossible.
Boundaries. The article treats the rank inside the quintet; the rank law for the operators on the algebra is treated in the article on the ten ranks.
The Spectral Rigidity
Proposition. Every element of $V_2$ has the characteristic polynomial $(\lambda^{2}-q/4)^{2}$ with $q=\operatorname{tr}(X^{2})$, so its spectrum is $\{\pm s,\pm s\}$ with $s^{2}=q/4$.
Proof. The trace and the cube trace vanish on the carrier, and the determinant equals $q^{2}/16$; the polynomial with these coefficients and a symmetric spectrum is $(\lambda^{2}-q/4)^{2}$, and the identity is verified numerically on random elements.
Corollary. The spectrum has at most two distinct values, each with multiplicity two.
Proof. The polynomial is the square of a quadratic.
Corollary. The element is singular exactly when $q=0$, and then it is nilpotent.
Proof. Singularity means a vanishing eigenvalue, and the spectrum is $\{\pm s,\pm s\}$, so $s=0$ and all eigenvalues vanish.
The reading. The quintet is the carrier whose spectrum is tied to a single invariant, so the rank takes only three values.
The Three Ranks
Proposition. The rank of a nonzero element of $V_2$ is four if $q\neq0$ and two if $q=0$.
Proof. For $q\neq0$ the four eigenvalues are nonzero, so the rank is four; for $q=0$ the element is nilpotent, its square vanishes, and its image is two-dimensional, as the explicit element below shows, so its rank is two.
Corollary. The carrier realises exactly the ranks zero, two and four.
Proof. The proposition and the origin.
Corollary. Rank one and rank three do not occur. A rank-three element would have one zero eigenvalue and three nonzero ones, which the spectrum $\{\pm s,\pm s\}$ forbids; a rank-one element would have the spectrum $\{\mu,0,0,0\}$, so tracelessness forces $\mu=0$ and the element would be a nilpotent of type $[2,1,1]$, while the nilpotents of the carrier have square zero and type $[2,2]$.
Proof. The spectrum of a rank-one element is $\{\mu,0,0,0\}$ and that of a rank-three element is $\{\mu,\nu,\nu,0\}$ up to order; the second has three nonzero entries with a single zero, which the form $\{\pm s,\pm s\}$ cannot produce. For the first, $\mu=0$ by tracelessness, and the nilpotents of the carrier satisfy $X^{2}=0$, so their rank is two.
The reading. The middle carrier avoids the odd ranks, and its two strata are the invertible elements and the nilpotent cone.
The Rank-Two Elements
Proposition. The element $E_{02}+E_{13}$ belongs to $V_2$, has rank two, and satisfies $(E_{02}+E_{13})^{2}=0$; the element $\tfrac12\operatorname{diag}(1,-1,-1,1)$ belongs to $V_2$, has rank four, and has the spectrum $\{\tfrac12,\tfrac12,-\tfrac12,-\tfrac12\}$.
Proof. Both are the projections onto the carrier of matrix units of the corresponding weight; the products are computed directly, since $E_{02}E_{13}=0$ and $E_{13}E_{02}=0$, and the diagonal element has the eigenvalues displayed.
Corollary. The rank-two elements are exactly the nonzero elements of the isotropic cone $q=0$, and they form the cone over a quadric of complex dimension three.
Proof. The proposition and the spectral rigidity.
Corollary. The rank-two stratum contains nilpotents of Jordan type $[2,2]$ and no other type, and it is not a single orbit.
Proof. A nilpotent of rank two with a vanishing square has two blocks of size two; the level sets of $q$ and the orbits of the copy give several orbits inside the cone.
The reading. The rank-two stratum is the nilpotent cone of the quintet, cut out by one quadratic equation.
The Jordan Types
Proposition. The Jordan types occurring in $V_2$ are $[1,1,1,1]$ for the rank-four elements, $[2,2]$ for the rank-two nilpotents and the type of the zero matrix at the origin.
Proof. The rank-four elements are semisimple with two double eigenvalues; the rank-two elements have square zero and rank two.
Corollary. The carrier contains no element with a single Jordan block and no block of size three.
Proof. The multiplicity is at most two and the square of every singular element vanishes.
Corollary. At order two the alternating square is one-dimensional and consists of the multiples of the alternating form, of rank two or zero.
Proof. The alternating square of a two-dimensional space is a line spanned by the form, whose matrix is invertible of rank two.
The reading. The quintet's Jordan types are the two-block types, and the alternating square at order two is the degenerate case with a single block of size two.
The Boundary
Against the trace form article. That article computes the form whose isotropic cone is the rank-two stratum.
Against the rank law. The quintet occupies the ranks two and four, so the middle carrier occupies the middle even ranks.
Against the septet. The septet realises rank one, because its top weight vector is a matrix unit.
A Final Observation
The cone and its rulings. The rank-two elements form the isotropic cone of the trace form, a quadric cone of complex dimension four in the five-dimensional carrier; the cone is ruled by the two families of rank-one directions of the alternating square, and each ruling is a family of minimal left ideals.
The rigidity. The absence of rank three is the sharpest sign of the rigidity of the quintet: in the septet the intermediate ranks occur, and in the triplet the intermediate rank two does not, so each carrier has its own pattern of realised ranks.
The Cone and Its Rulings
The ruling by ideals. Every rank-two element of the quintet is the sum of two rank-one bispinors, one from each family of minimal left ideals, and the decomposition is not unique; the cone is therefore ruled by the ideals, and the two rulings are the two families of lines on the quadric.
The two orbits. The rank-two elements split into the orbit of the nilpotent of type $[2,2]$ and the orbits obtained from it by the action of the copy; the cone is the closure of a single orbit in the space of the carrier for the smaller group, and several orbits for the larger one.
The scale. The cone is invariant under multiplication by scalars, so its projectivisation is a quadric surface in the projective space of dimension four; the quadric has two families of lines, and each family is a ruling by the ideals.
The reading. The rank-two stratum of the quintet is the projectivised quadric with its two rulings, and the two rulings are the algebraic trace of the two families of bispinors.
The Check of the Multiplicities
The two eigenvalues. The spectrum is $\{\pm s,\pm s\}$ with each value of multiplicity two, so the ratio of the two nonzero eigenvalues is minus one and the projective spectrum is constant; the carrier has a single projective spectral class, and the only variable is the scale.
Summary
Every element of the carrier of label two has the spectrum $\{\pm s,\pm s\}$ with $s^{2}=\operatorname{tr}(X^{2})/4$, so its rank is four when the trace of the square does not vanish, two when it vanishes at a nonzero element, and zero at the origin. Rank one and rank three are impossible, since each would require an eigenvalue of multiplicity one.
The rank-two elements are the nilpotents of type $[2,2]$ and form the isotropic cone; the explicit element $E_{02}+E_{13}$ is one of them, and $\tfrac12\operatorname{diag}(1,-1,-1,1)$ is an element of rank four.
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $q=\operatorname{tr}(X^{2})$ | the invariant parameter |
| $\{\pm s,\pm s\}$ | the spectrum |
| $0,2,4$ | the three ranks |
| $[2,2]$ | the nilpotent Jordan type |
Further Reading
- Introduction to the Spin-Two Carrier at $n=4$: the Alternating Square, for the carrier.
- The Spin-Two Carrier and the Trace Form at $n=4$, for the form.
- The Spin-Three Carrier and the Rank Strata at $n=4$, for the septet.
- The Spin-One Carrier and the Rank Strata at $n=4$, for the triplet.
- The Spin-Zero Carrier and the Rank Strata at $n=4$, for the scalars.