Where the Half-Integers Go in $M_4(\mathbb{C})$
Introduction
The subject. The algebra has four labels, all integers, and its module has one label, $\tfrac32$, which is not among them. The half-integer does not disappear: it goes into the weights of the module and of its minimal left ideals, into the eigenvalues of the elements of the algebra, and into the corners of the block display.
The order of the article. The first section lists the labels of the algebra and of the module. The second explains why the algebra's labels cannot be half-integers. The third shows where the half-integers reappear as weights. The fourth shows where they reappear as eigenvalues, with the pair $(\tfrac12,\tfrac12)$ and the corners. The fifth draws the lesson and the boundary.
It assumes The Clebsch–Gordan Decomposition of $M_4(\mathbb{C})$ for the labels, The Minimal Left Ideals of $M_4(\mathbb{C})$ and the Module $V_{3/2}$ for the ideal. The row at order two is Where the Half-Integers Go in the Biquaternion Algebra.
The result in one line. The algebra carries the integer labels $0,1,2,3$, the module carries $\tfrac32$, and a half-integer eigenvalue of an algebra element is not a half-integer label.
Boundaries. The article does not re-prove the decomposition or the ideal structure; it locates the half-integer in each of the four places where it occurs and separates the label from the eigenvalue.
The Two Lists
Proposition. The carriers of the algebra have labels $0,1,2,3$ and dimensions $1,3,5,7$; the module has label $\tfrac32$ and dimension $4$.
Proof. The tensor square of $V_{3/2}$ decomposes into the labels $0,1,2,3$, and the module's dimension is $2\cdot\tfrac32+1=4$.
Corollary. The label $\tfrac32$ is not a carrier label, and no carrier has dimension $4$.
Proof. The labels are integers and the dimensions $2k+1$ are odd, while $4$ is even.
Corollary. The weights of the algebra are integers and the weights of the module are half-integers.
Proof. The algebra's weights are differences of module weights, and the difference of two half-integers is an integer.
The reading. The two lists are the two halves of the same statement: the module has the half-integer label and the algebra the integer ones, and neither list can be deduced from the other without the tensor rule.
Why the Labels Are Integers
Proposition. If a label $j$ occurs in the decomposition of the algebra, then $j$ is an integer, because $j$ is a difference of two weights of the module and the module's weights are all congruent to $\tfrac32$ modulo $1$.
Proof. The weights of $V_{3/2}$ are $\tfrac32,\tfrac12,-\tfrac12,-\tfrac32$; each is congruent to $\tfrac12$ modulo $1$, so the difference of two of them is congruent to $0$.
Corollary. The four labels $3,2,1,0$ are the integers between $0$ and $2j$, and the half-integer $2j-1=2$ is not among them because it is not a label at all: the labels are integers and the values $2j-k$ are the integers $0,\dots,3$.
Proof. The labels are integers and their values run from $0$ to $2j=3$.
Corollary. At half-integer $j$ the ring of labels is the integers and the module is the only object with a half-integer label; at integer $j$ the module itself has an integer label and appears as a carrier.
Proof. The two cases $2j$ odd and $2j$ even.
The reading. The half-integer does not disappear from the algebra; it is pushed into the weights. The next section follows it there.
The Half-Integers as Weights
Proposition. The module has the four weights $\pm\tfrac32,\pm\tfrac12$, and every minimal left ideal, being isomorphic to the module, has the same four weights under the left action of the diagonal generator.
Proof. The module's weight string is the ladder from $\tfrac32$ down to $-\tfrac32$; a left ideal is isomorphic to the module as a left module, and the diagonal generator acts by the same weights.
Corollary. The weights $\tfrac32$ and $\tfrac12$ occur in the ideal and in no carrier of the algebra; the algebra's weight spaces have integer weights only.
Proof. The algebra's weights are differences of module weights, hence integers; the ideal's weights are the module's.
Corollary. The raising operator moves the weight $\tfrac12$ to $\tfrac32$ inside the ideal, and the lowering operator moves $\tfrac32$ to $\tfrac12$; both stay inside the ideal.
Proof. The ideal is invariant under the left action, which contains the two operators.
The numerical check. The diagonal generator in the weight basis is diagonal with the entries $\tfrac32,\tfrac12,-\tfrac12,-\tfrac32$, and the raising operator has nonzero entries only between consecutive weights, of the values $\sqrt3,2,\sqrt3$.
Proof. The ladder relations $J_+v_m=\sqrt{(j-m)(j+m+1)}\,v_{m+1}$ with $j=\tfrac32$.
The Half-Integers as Eigenvalues
Proposition. The algebra contains the element with eigenvalues $\tfrac12,\tfrac12,-\tfrac12,-\tfrac12$, namely the diagonal matrix with those entries in the weight basis, and this element decomposes as a sum of a vector in $V_1$ and a vector in $V_3$ with squared norms in the ratio $4:1$.
Proof. The element is diagonal, hence an algebra element; projecting it on the four carriers gives norms $0.894$ and $0.447$ on $V_1$ and $V_3$ and zero on the other two, whose squares are in the ratio $4:1$ and sum to one.
Corollary. A half-integer eigenvalue does not make the element a half-integer object: its weights are differences of weights and its label is an integer.
Proof. The element lies in $V_1\oplus V_3$, and its eigenvalues are the diagonal entries, not the weights.
Proposition. In the block display of the module by the two halves $\{v_{3/2},v_{1/2}\}$ and $\{v_{-1/2},v_{-3/2}\}$, the diagonal blocks carry the weights $\tfrac32,\tfrac12$ and $-\tfrac12,-\tfrac32$, and the off-diagonal corners carry the entries that connect a weight of one half with a weight of the other.
Proof. The weight basis orders the four vectors by decreasing weight, and the matrix of an operator in that basis has the block structure of the two halves.
Corollary. The extreme eigenvalues $\pm\tfrac32$ occur on the diagonal of the display, and the corners connect them to the weights $\mp\tfrac12$, so a corner element has eigenvalues differing by integers.
Proof. The corner entries have weights $\pm1$ and $\pm2$, being differences of a weight of the first half and a weight of the second; the eigenvalues of a corner element are computed from its $2\times2$ blocks and differ by integer amounts.
The reading. Half-integers occur in three places: as the module's label, as the module's weights, and as eigenvalues of algebra elements. Only the first two are representation-theoretic; the third is a statement about a chosen basis.
The Lesson
Proposition. The label of an object under the copy is a half-integer exactly when the object is a module and not a carrier; the algebra is a carrier sum and its labels are integers.
Proof. The carriers are the isotypic pieces of the algebra, whose labels are differences of module weights.
Corollary. The rule "the algebra has integer labels, the module has the half-integer label" holds at every even order, and at odd orders the module's label is an integer and the distinction disappears.
Proof. The label of the module is $\tfrac{n-1}{2}$, an integer exactly for odd $n$.
The boundary. The article does not claim that the half-integer is absent from the algebra: it is present as a weight of the ideal and as an eigenvalue. What is absent from the algebra is a carrier with a half-integer label.
Summary
The algebra has the labels $0,1,2,3$ and the module has $\tfrac32$. The algebra's labels are integers because they are differences of the module's weights, which are all congruent to $\tfrac12$ modulo one.
The half-integer survives in three places: as the label of the module and of every minimal left ideal, as the weights $\pm\tfrac32,\pm\tfrac12$ of that ideal, and as the eigenvalues of algebra elements such as the diagonal element with entries $\tfrac12,\tfrac12,-\tfrac12,-\tfrac12$, which lies in $V_1\oplus V_3$ with squared norms in the ratio $4:1$.
A half-integer eigenvalue is not a half-integer label. The distinction is the content of the article, and it is the reason the algebra has four integer labels while its module has one half-integer label.
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $0,1,2,3$ | the labels of the carriers |
| $\tfrac32$ | the label of the module |
| $\pm\tfrac32,\pm\tfrac12$ | the weights of the module and of the ideal |
| $\operatorname{diag}(\tfrac12,\tfrac12,-\tfrac12,-\tfrac12)$ | an algebra element with half-integer eigenvalues |
| $2j=n-1$ | the identity fixing the slot |
Further Reading
- The Slot and the Summand at $n=4$, for the identity $2j=n-1$.
- The Minimal Left Ideals of $M_4(\mathbb{C})$ and the Module $V_{3/2}$, for the ideal.
- The Four Weights of the Module and the Half Angle at $n=4$, for the weights.
- Where the Half-Integers Go in the Biquaternion Algebra, for the row at order two.
- Why the Conjugation Labels Are Integer at $n=4$, for the argument from the difference of weights.