The Stueckelberg Mechanism for a Massive Abelian Vector in Biquaternionic Form
Introduction
The object. A mass term $-\tfrac12\mu^2 A_\mu A^\mu$ is not invariant under an abelian gauge transformation $A_\mu\mapsto A_\mu-\partial_\mu\Gamma$. A massive vector is therefore either a gauge field whose symmetry has been broken by hand, or a gauge field whose mass is carried by an extra field. The Stueckelberg mechanism is the second route: a scalar is introduced that shifts under the same transformation, the combination
$$ A_{\mu,\mathrm u}=A_\mu-\partial_\mu\xi $$
is invariant, and the mass term written in that combination costs no symmetry.
What this article is. The general construction, with no sector attached. It states the obstruction, the invariant mass term, the gauge fixing, the degree-of-freedom count, and the relation to the abelian Higgs. The construction applies to any abelian gauge field, and this category contains one such field.
Where the applications are.
- The electroweak sector, where the massive $W$ and $Z$ are the case in point. The mechanism used there is not this one: the sector uses the Higgs, and the Stueckelberg route is the alternative it does not take. The application article is The Stueckelberg Mechanism in Biquaternionic Form, which works the construction in the framework's own notation and states which of the two routes the algebra can host.
- The strong sector, nowhere. $SU(3)$ is unbroken and its gauge bosons are massless.
The Proca Obstruction
The Lagrangian of a massive vector with no scalar,
$$ \mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{P}}=-\tfrac12\langle\tilde F\rangle_{\natural}-\tfrac12\mu^2\langle\tilde A_\Phi\rangle_{\natural}, $$
is not invariant under $\tilde A_\Phi\mapsto\tilde A_\Phi-\tilde\nabla_\Phi\Gamma$, because the mass term is quadratic in the connection while the transformation is affine. The obstruction is not a technicality of notation: a mass term is a length, and a gauge symmetry forbids one.
The consequences that follow from the obstruction. The propagator of the Proca field has the form $(-g_{\mu\nu}+k_\mu k_\nu/\mu^2)/(k^2-\mu^2)$, whose longitudinal part grows with energy; the theory is not renormalisable by power counting; and the longitudinal mode is put in by hand as a third polarisation rather than arising from a field.
The Invariant Mass Term
Introduce a scalar $\xi$ that shifts under the gauge transformation,
$$ \tilde A_\Phi\mapsto\tilde A_\Phi-\tilde\nabla_\Phi\Gamma, \qquad \xi\mapsto\xi+\Gamma . $$
Then
$$ \boxed{\;\tilde A_{\Phi,\mathrm u}=\tilde A_{\Phi}-\tilde\nabla_\Phi\xi\;} $$
is invariant, and the mass term written in it,
$$ \boxed{\;\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{S}}=-\tfrac12\mathrm{Re}\langle\tilde F\rangle_{\natural}-\tfrac12\mu^2\langle\tilde A_{\Phi,\mathrm u}\rangle_{\natural}\;} $$
is invariant for every $\Gamma$. The gauge group is unchanged — the scalar shifts with the same parameter as the connection, so no new symmetry is introduced — and the mass is now compatible with it.
The equations. Variation with respect to the vector gives
$$ \boxed{\;\tilde\nabla_\Phi\tilde F-\mu^2\tilde A_{\Phi,\mathrm u}=0\;} $$
and variation with respect to the scalar gives the constraint $\tilde\nabla_\Phi\tilde A_{\Phi,\mathrm u}=0$, so the invariant combination is transverse. The four components of $A$ and the one of $\xi$ reduce to three propagating polarisations: the scalar is eaten.
The counting. A massless vector has two polarisations and a shift scalar has one; a massive vector has three. The count is preserved, and nothing is lost — the scalar's degree of freedom has become the longitudinal polarisation.
Gauge Fixing and the Relation to the Abelian Higgs
The unitary gauge. Setting $\xi=0$ removes the scalar from the Lagrangian and leaves the Proca form, at the price of making the gauge non-manifest. This is why the mechanism is often described as "the scalar is gauged away": the description is correct in that gauge and misleading outside it.
The relation to the abelian Higgs. The two Lagrangians are the same object. In the Higgs case a complex scalar acquires a vacuum expectation value $v$, the phase is the Goldstone, the radial field is the physical scalar, and the mass is $\mu=gv$. In the Stueckelberg case the scalar is not a Higgs, has no potential, and the mass is a parameter. The difference is interpretive and observable: the Higgs leaves a physical scalar and a symmetry-breaking vacuum, the Stueckelberg leaves neither.
Renormalisability. The abelian Stueckelberg theory is renormalisable. The non-abelian version is not, in the same form, because the shift field in a non-abelian theory is not a standard field and does not improve the power counting. The boundary is the abelian case, and it is the case that arises here.
What the Framework Supplies
- Supplied. The invariant $\langle\tilde A_\Phi\rangle_{\natural}$ and the covariant derivative $\tilde\nabla_\Phi$, which are what the construction is written in, and a central phase that is abelian, so the abelian restriction is the framework's own situation.
- Imported. The mechanism itself, the shift field and the counting. These are standard field theory, transcribed.
- Not supplied. A broken symmetry. The framework's scalar is a singlet of its compact factor and a central scalar cannot break the compact group, so the Higgs route is not available and this is the route that is.
Where the application is. The Stueckelberg Mechanism in Biquaternionic Form carries the construction in the framework's notation, fixes the gauge, counts the degrees of freedom and states which parts of the algebra's reading carry over and which do not.
Summary of Notation
| Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| $\tilde A_\Phi$ | the abelian connection |
| $\Gamma$ | the gauge parameter |
| $\xi$ | the shift scalar |
| $\tilde A_{\Phi,\mathrm u}$ | the invariant combination |
| $\mu$ | the vector mass |
| $v$ | the Higgs vacuum expectation value, for comparison only |
Further Reading
- E. C. G. Stueckelberg, "Die Wechselwirkungskräfte in der Elektrodynamik und in der Feldtheorie der Kernkräfte," Helvetica Physica Acta 11 (1938) 225, the original.
- H. Ruegg and M. Ruiz-Altaba, "The Stueckelberg Field," International Journal of Modern Physics A 19 (2004) 3265–3347, the modern treatment.
- M. E. Peskin and D. V. Schroeder, An Introduction to Quantum Field Theory, Chapter 21, for the counting against the Higgs.